No. 90
The Verateca TablePeriodic Table of Supplements

Creatine monohydrate vs HCl: what did studies compare?

Creatine monohydrate and creatine hydrochloride (HCl) have been compared in small human studies. Those studies did not establish HCl superiority for the strength or body-composition outcomes measured.[1][2] They also do not establish that the forms are equivalent, or that smaller HCl servings give the same results.[1][2]

NIH describes monohydrate as the most widely used and studied form of creatine.[3]

Forms, amounts and solubility

Monohydrate combines creatine with a water molecule. HCl is a hydrochloride salt of creatine.[1] A comparison needs the named compound and its amount, alongside the outcome measured. The mass of a creatine compound includes more than creatine itself.[1][3]

Solubility describes how much dissolves under specified conditions. It does not directly measure the amount reaching human muscle.[4] A laboratory study found greater solubility for HCl in unbuffered water than for monohydrate.[4] Permeability through cultured intestinal cells did not differ significantly between those forms.[4] The researchers tested compounds and cultured cells in the lab.[4]

UNeMed funded the laboratory study.[4]

Direct comparisons in people

Each study shows what happened under its particular conditions, doses and duration. A change within a group and a difference between groups answer different questions.

Resistance training and the creatine forms

Eghbali and colleagues randomized 40 men aged 18–25 into groups of 10 for 8 weeks of resistance training.[1]

Study groupDaily study amount
HCl0.03 g/kg body weight.[1]
Monohydrate without loading0.03 g/kg body weight.[1]
Monohydrate with loading0.3 g/kg for 5 days; then 0.03 g/kg for 51 days.[1]
PlaceboPlacebo alongside the same training program.[1]

These are experimental conditions. Amounts expressed per kilogram depend on body weight; matching compound weights also does not guarantee matching creatine content.[1]

Strength and estimated body-composition changes differed from placebo in the creatine groups.[1] HCl did not differ significantly from either monohydrate group on those outcomes.[1] The study did not directly measure muscle creatine accumulation or comparative absorption.[1] Small groups limit what an undetected difference can establish.

Japan's Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology funded the study through grant 20H00574.[1] The authors declared no conflict of interest.[1]

Elite team-sport athletes

A separate randomized, triple-blind study involved 31 male and female handball and softball athletes over 8 weeks.[2] Allocation was 11 to monohydrate, 10 to HCl and 10 to maltodextrin placebo.[2] The published abstract reports a 5 g/day protocol and gives no table of doses by group.[2]

Between-group differences were not statistically significant for the measured strength, jump or body-composition outcomes.[2] Reported changes within the creatine groups do not establish an advantage over placebo.

The abstract gives no confidence intervals or funding details.[2] Richard Kreider and Diego Bonilla disclosed roles on an Alzchem-sponsored scientific advisory board.[2] Bonilla also disclosed KreaFood and CREAS project roles.[2]

The limits of a smaller-serving claim

These comparisons do not establish a conversion between a small HCl serving and a larger monohydrate serving.[1][2] The laboratory solubility result also cannot supply that conversion.[4] Dissolving in water, crossing an intestinal cell layer, accumulating in muscle and changing exercise performance are separate measurements.[1][4]

The relevant comparison therefore includes the exact form, daily amount, duration and measured result. Neither a smaller scoop nor a more soluble compound, by itself, answers the question about training outcomes.

Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.

More about creatine

Sources

  1. Eghbali E, Arazi H, Suzuki K. Supplementing With Which Form of Creatine (Hydrochloride or Monohydrate) Alongside Resistance Training Can Have More Impacts on Anabolic/Catabolic Hormones, Strength and Body Composition? Physiological Research. 2024. Full text. Methods, Table 3, results and disclosures. PMID 39545789. ↩
  2. Londoño-Velásquez D, et al. Creatine monohydrate versus creatine hydrochloride on strength and body composition in elite team-sport athletes: A placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial comparing low dosages. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2025. Published abstract. Abstract and disclosures; no separate full methods or results tables in this publication. ↩
  3. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Dietary Supplements for Exercise and Athletic Performance: Health Professional Fact Sheet. Creatine section. ↩
  4. Gufford BT, et al. Physicochemical characterization of creatine N-methylguanidinium salts. Journal of Dietary Supplements. 2010. Abstract · Published paper in a public patent record. Table 1, permeability results and funding disclosure. ↩

You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.