Creatine monohydrate and creatine hydrochloride (HCl) have been compared in small human studies. Those studies did not establish HCl superiority for the strength or body-composition outcomes measured.[1][2] They also do not establish that the forms are equivalent, or that smaller HCl servings give the same results.[1][2]
NIH describes monohydrate as the most widely used and studied form of creatine.[3]
Forms, amounts and solubility
Monohydrate combines creatine with a water molecule. HCl is a hydrochloride salt of creatine.[1] A comparison needs the named compound and its amount, alongside the outcome measured. The mass of a creatine compound includes more than creatine itself.[1][3]
Solubility describes how much dissolves under specified conditions. It does not directly measure the amount reaching human muscle.[4] A laboratory study found greater solubility for HCl in unbuffered water than for monohydrate.[4] Permeability through cultured intestinal cells did not differ significantly between those forms.[4] The researchers tested compounds and cultured cells in the lab.[4]
UNeMed funded the laboratory study.[4]
Direct comparisons in people
Each study shows what happened under its particular conditions, doses and duration. A change within a group and a difference between groups answer different questions.
Resistance training and the creatine forms
Eghbali and colleagues randomized 40 men aged 18–25 into groups of 10 for 8 weeks of resistance training.[1]
| Study group | Daily study amount |
|---|---|
| HCl | 0.03 g/kg body weight.[1] |
| Monohydrate without loading | 0.03 g/kg body weight.[1] |
| Monohydrate with loading | 0.3 g/kg for 5 days; then 0.03 g/kg for 51 days.[1] |
| Placebo | Placebo alongside the same training program.[1] |
These are experimental conditions. Amounts expressed per kilogram depend on body weight; matching compound weights also does not guarantee matching creatine content.[1]
Strength and estimated body-composition changes differed from placebo in the creatine groups.[1] HCl did not differ significantly from either monohydrate group on those outcomes.[1] The study did not directly measure muscle creatine accumulation or comparative absorption.[1] Small groups limit what an undetected difference can establish.
Japan's Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology funded the study through grant 20H00574.[1] The authors declared no conflict of interest.[1]
Elite team-sport athletes
A separate randomized, triple-blind study involved 31 male and female handball and softball athletes over 8 weeks.[2] Allocation was 11 to monohydrate, 10 to HCl and 10 to maltodextrin placebo.[2] The published abstract reports a 5 g/day protocol and gives no table of doses by group.[2]
Between-group differences were not statistically significant for the measured strength, jump or body-composition outcomes.[2] Reported changes within the creatine groups do not establish an advantage over placebo.
The abstract gives no confidence intervals or funding details.[2] Richard Kreider and Diego Bonilla disclosed roles on an Alzchem-sponsored scientific advisory board.[2] Bonilla also disclosed KreaFood and CREAS project roles.[2]
The limits of a smaller-serving claim
These comparisons do not establish a conversion between a small HCl serving and a larger monohydrate serving.[1][2] The laboratory solubility result also cannot supply that conversion.[4] Dissolving in water, crossing an intestinal cell layer, accumulating in muscle and changing exercise performance are separate measurements.[1][4]
The relevant comparison therefore includes the exact form, daily amount, duration and measured result. Neither a smaller scoop nor a more soluble compound, by itself, answers the question about training outcomes.
Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.
More about creatine
Sources
- Eghbali E, Arazi H, Suzuki K. Supplementing With Which Form of Creatine (Hydrochloride or Monohydrate) Alongside Resistance Training Can Have More Impacts on Anabolic/Catabolic Hormones, Strength and Body Composition? Physiological Research. 2024. Full text. Methods, Table 3, results and disclosures. PMID 39545789. ↩
- Londoño-Velásquez D, et al. Creatine monohydrate versus creatine hydrochloride on strength and body composition in elite team-sport athletes: A placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial comparing low dosages. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2025. Published abstract. Abstract and disclosures; no separate full methods or results tables in this publication. ↩
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Dietary Supplements for Exercise and Athletic Performance: Health Professional Fact Sheet. Creatine section. ↩
- Gufford BT, et al. Physicochemical characterization of creatine N-methylguanidinium salts. Journal of Dietary Supplements. 2010. Abstract · Published paper in a public patent record. Table 1, permeability results and funding disclosure. ↩
You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.