Compare grams of protein per serving, then the essential amino acids in that protein. In one lab study, whey protein was 43% essential amino acids and the plant proteins studied ranged from 21% to 37%.[1] A trial gave the same listed weight of pea isolate or whey concentrate alongside training. Another study compared vegans and omnivores who trained with the same target for total daily protein. Neither found a statistically significant difference between the protein groups in the muscle or strength outcomes it measured.[2][5]
Grams of protein, then amino acids
The weight of a scoop includes flavors and other ingredients, so the first number to compare is grams of protein per serving on the label.[4] The second is what that protein contains:
| Protein | Essential amino acids, share of protein | Leucine, share of protein | Low in |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whey | 43%[1] | 11.0%[1] | — |
| Soy | 27%[1] | — | Methionine[1] |
| Pea | 30%[1] | — | Methionine[1] |
| Brown rice | 28%[1] | — | Lysine[1] |
| Hemp | 23%[1] | 5.1%[1] | Lysine[1] |
Measured in one lab study of 35 commercial powders; suppliers donated the samples, and tryptophan was not measured.[1] A dash means no figure given here.
In the same study, 25 g of whey protein held about 2.7 g of leucine; the same leucine took about 37 g of brown rice protein, 38 g of pea or 40 g of soy.[1] The authors calculated that 50/50 blends of a protein low in methionine (soy or pea) and one low in lysine (rice or hemp) give a more complete set of essential amino acids.[1]
What trials found
Pea against whey — Babault and colleagues, 2015. The trial randomized 161 men aged 18 to 35. All did 12 weeks of arm strength training. The protein groups received 25 g of pea protein isolate or whey protein concentrate twice a day. The control took placebo powder on the same schedule. The analysis included 137 men. Biceps thickness rose 13.4% with pea, 15.3% with whey and 10.7% with placebo. The between-group difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.09). Strength increased in all groups without a significant between-group difference. Funding: Roquette, the pea protein maker, supported the study, and three authors worked there.[2]
Soy against whey, 9 studies — Messina and colleagues, 2018. A meta-analysis of studies lasting 6 weeks or more found that strength and lean mass changes did not differ between soy and whey.[3] Funding: see the publication; the first author's affiliation is Nutrition Matters, Inc.[3]
Vegans and omnivores — Hevia-Larraín and colleagues, 2021. Young men who already followed a vegan or omnivorous diet trained for 12 weeks. They added soy protein or whey, respectively, to reach the same total protein target of 1.6 g per kg a day. Muscle and strength gains did not differ significantly. Participants chose their prior diet and were not randomized. Funding: the São Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) supported the study. Coauthor Stuart Phillips disclosed industry payments, equity, grants and patents outside this study.[5]
The first trial used the same listed weight of pea isolate and whey concentrate per dose. The second matched the total daily protein target from food and supplements. Neither tested replacing a larger whey serving with a smaller plant serving.[2][5]
Comparing a serving
- Protein per scoop. The grams of protein on the label are the number to compare; the scoop weight includes other ingredients.[4]
- Total daily protein. Food supplies most protein; the protein guide gives the daily amounts.[6]
- Allergens. Whey is a milk protein; soy is also a major allergen that US labels must name.[7]
Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.
Sources
- Gorissen SHM, and colleagues. Protein content and amino acid composition of commercially available plant-based protein isolates. Amino Acids. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00726-018-2640-5 ↩
- Babault N, and colleagues. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12970-014-0064-5 — PubMed 25628520. full text. Funding: Roquette provided financial support; three authors employed by the funder. ↩
- Messina M, and colleagues. International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1123/ijsnem.2018-0071 — PubMed 29722584. abstract. Funding: not read. ↩
- US Food and Drug Administration. How to Understand and Use the Nutrition Facts Label. https://www.fda.gov/food/nutrition-facts-label/how-understand-and-use-nutrition-facts-label ↩
- Hevia-Larraín V and colleagues. Sports Medicine. 2021. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-021-01434-9 — PubMed 33599941. Full report, Methods, Funding and Conflict of interest. FAPESP grant 2016/22083-3. ↩
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Dietary Supplements for Exercise and Athletic Performance: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals — Protein. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/ExerciseAndAthleticPerformance-HealthProfessional/ ↩
- US Food and Drug Administration. Have Food Allergies? Read the Label. https://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm254504.htm ↩
You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.