Adults aged 60–80 took beta-alanine for 10 weeks; one mood score differed from dummy tablets, other tests did not.
Trial · 50 per group randomized; 79 completed (38 and 41) · 10 weeks · maker-funded
Ostfeld et al., Nutrients, 2023
Terms and sources
- Adults aged 60–80
- 100 adults, 29 men and 71 women, recruited through community centers in Israel. A physician screened out neurological and other conditions. 79 completed the study.
- took beta-alanine
- 2.4 g a day as slow-release tablets: two 600 mg tablets twice a day with meals. Natural Alternatives International provided the tablets and the dummy tablets. The article names Natural Alternative Inc. as the funder.
- one mood score differed
- A 15-item questionnaire on low mood for older adults. The groups differed; scores fell with beta-alanine and did not change with the dummy tablets.
- dummy tablets
- placebo: the same tablets with hydroxypropyl methylcellulose in place of beta-alanine. Assignment was random and double-blind.
- other tests did not
- These did not differ between groups: a cognitive screening test, a color-word test and six mood scales. Nor did a 10-item questionnaire on tension symptoms, grip strength or a chair-rise test. In a subgroup with lower screening scores at the start, the screening score rose more with beta-alanine. No adverse events were reported.
Study · Free full text · about 21 min to read
Free full text on PubMed Central. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
In Israel, 100 adults aged 60–80 took slow-release beta-alanine or dummy tablets for 10 weeks. The dose was 2.4 g a day. Assignment was random and double-blind. 79 completed. Cognitive tests, mood scales, a tension questionnaire, grip and chair rises did not differ between groups. Scores on a 15-item low-mood questionnaire fell with beta-alanine and differed between groups. No adverse events were reported. Funding: the article names Natural Alternative Inc. as the funder. Natural Alternatives International provided the tablets.
Adults about 71 had a nutrition drink with or without beta-alanine; a cycling fatigue measure differed, grip strength did not.
Trial · 20 + 19 + 21 randomized; 44 completed (16, 15, 13) · 12 weeks · industry-funded
McCormack et al., Experimental Gerontology, 2013
Terms and sources
- Adults about 71
- 60 men and women in the US, average age 71. 44 completed the 12 weeks.
- a nutrition drink
- 8 oz, 230 kcal and 12 g protein, twice a day for 12 weeks. One group's drink had 800 mg of beta-alanine per serving and one had 1,200 mg. We converted these: 1.6 or 2.4 g a day. Europe PMC lists Abbott Nutrition as the funder. We could not read the article's funding section.
- without beta-alanine
- placebo: the same drink without beta-alanine. Assignment was random and double-blind.
- a cycling fatigue measure differed
- On a cycle test, the power at which muscle fatigue began rose 17.8% and 13.6% with beta-alanine. With the drink alone it fell 6.3%. The differences were statistically significant.
- grip strength did not
- Body composition and grip did not change. A chair-stand score rose with the higher dose and with the drink alone. The lower dose did not differ from the drink alone.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Abstract only. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
In the US, 60 adults aged about 71 had a nutrition drink twice a day for 12 weeks. The drink had no beta-alanine, 800 mg or 1,200 mg per serving. 44 completed. On a cycle test, the power at which muscle fatigue began rose in both beta-alanine groups. It fell with the drink alone. The differences were statistically significant. Body composition and grip did not change. We read only the abstract. Funding: Europe PMC lists Abbott Nutrition as the funder. We could not read the article's funding section.
Recreationally trained adults took beta-alanine tablets; high-speed running to exhaustion did not differ from dummy tablets.
Trial · 26 beta-alanine and 24 dummy tablets randomized · not stated in the abstract · funding not stated
Smith-Ryan et al., Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2012
Terms and sources
- Recreationally trained adults
- 50 people in the US. The abstract calls them men but reports results for men and women. It does not give the length of supplementation.
- beta-alanine tablets
- Two 800 mg tablets three times a day, 4.8 g a day. The abstract names CarnoSyn tablets.
- high-speed running to exhaustion
- Three runs at 90–110% of peak speed, each lasting about 2–5 minutes. Critical velocity and anaerobic running capacity were calculated from them.
- did not differ
- No statistically significant differences between groups in critical velocity, running capacity or time to exhaustion.
- dummy tablets
- placebo: maltodextrin tablets on the same schedule. Assignment was random and double-blind.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Abstract only. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
In the US, 50 recreationally trained adults took 4.8 g of beta-alanine or dummy tablets a day. Assignment was random and double-blind. They ran three high-speed runs to exhaustion of about 2–5 minutes. Critical velocity, anaerobic running capacity and time to exhaustion did not differ between groups. The abstract calls the group men but reports results for men and women. It does not give the length of supplementation. We read only the abstract. Funding: not checked.
Elite swimmers took beta-alanine; race times showed no clear difference from dummy tablets, training times did at 4 weeks.
Trial · 60 swimmers volunteered and 10 left before supplementation; the paper does not say how many were randomized; 41 were analyzed · 10 weeks · maker-supplied
Chung et al., Nutrients, 2012
Terms and sources
- Elite swimmers
- 41 national and international-level swimmers in Australia, 23 men and 18 women, average age about 22, from 14 squads.
- took beta-alanine
- 4.8 g a day for 4 weeks, then 3.2 g a day, 10 weeks in total. Slow-release tablets (Musashi, as the paper names it), re-pressed to match the dummy tablets. Swimming Australia and Victoria University funded it; Musashi Australia provided the beta-alanine.
- no clear difference
- The authors used magnitude-based inference, not significance tests. They rated the difference in race times as unclear. Blood pH and bicarbonate did not clearly differ.
- dummy tablets
- placebo: maltodextrin tablets of the same appearance. Swimmers were paired by sex, event and level, then assigned at random.
- training times did at 4 weeks
- Training-set times were 1.3% faster than with the dummy tablets at 4 weeks; at 10 weeks the difference was unclear. Lactate after training was lower, a small effect. 10 of 22 swimmers on beta-alanine who answered a survey reported mild tingling.
Study · Free full text · about 19 min to read
Free full text on PubMed Central. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
In Australia, elite swimmers were paired and randomly assigned to slow-release beta-alanine or dummy tablets for 10 weeks. The dose was 4.8 g a day for 4 weeks, then 3.2 g. 41 were analyzed. The authors used magnitude-based inference. Race times did not clearly differ. Training-set times were faster at 4 weeks but not clearly at 10 weeks. 10 of 22 survey answers on beta-alanine reported mild tingling. Funding: Swimming Australia and Victoria University; Musashi Australia provided the beta-alanine.
Trained cyclists and untrained men took beta-alanine; total work in four sprints was higher than with dummy capsules.
Trial · 40 randomized within trained and untrained strata; 39 completed · 4 weeks · industry author
de Salles Painelli et al., Amino Acids, 2014
Terms and sources
- Trained cyclists and untrained men
- 40 young men in Brazil: 20 endurance-trained cyclists and 20 recreationally active men. One cyclist withdrew with an injury.
- took beta-alanine
- 6.4 g a day for 4 weeks: two 800 mg capsules four times a day. The capsules held carboxymethyl cellulose to slow absorption. The paper names CarnoSyn from Compound Solutions Inc. One author is an independent consultant to Natural Alternatives International, per the article.
- total work in four sprints
- Four 30-second all-out cycling sprints with 3 minutes of rest.
- was higher
- Total work rose by 1,663 J with beta-alanine. With the dummy capsules it changed by −832 J, not significantly. The difference between groups was statistically significant in trained and in untrained men. Mean and peak power across the four sprints also showed significant group-by-time differences. 3 of 20 people on beta-alanine reported mild tingling.
- dummy capsules
- placebo: dextrose capsules. Assignment was random, matched by work in a practice test, and double-blind.
Study · Free full text · about 20 min to read
Free full text on PubMed Central. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
In Brazil, 20 trained cyclists and 20 untrained men were randomly assigned to beta-alanine or dummy capsules for 4 weeks. The dose was 6.4 g a day. Double-blind. 39 completed. They did four 30-second all-out cycling sprints before and after. Total work rose with beta-alanine; with the dummy capsules it did not change significantly. The difference was statistically significant in both groups. 3 of 20 reported mild tingling. Funding: FAPESP and CNPq grants. One author is an independent consultant to Natural Alternatives International.
Male students took 2 g of beta-alanine daily; blood lactate after cycling was lower than with dummy capsules.
Trial · 20 beta-alanine and 19 dummy capsules; all completed · 6 weeks
Ghiasvand et al., 2012
Terms and sources
- Male students
- 39 male physical education students in Iran, average age about 21, active but not professional athletes.
- 2 g of beta-alanine daily
- Five 400 mg capsules a day for 6 weeks. The paper names Ajinomoto as the source of the beta-alanine. The Methods say both four and five doses a day. The Esfahan Sport Medicine Association funded it, per the article.
- blood lactate
- Measured after a graded cycling test. The paper compares oxygen uptake and time to exhaustion only within each group. Its Results say time to exhaustion fell with beta-alanine; its Discussion says it rose. We could not read the table with the numbers.
- was lower
- The difference was statistically significant. No one reported side effects.
- dummy capsules
- placebo: dextrose capsules of the same appearance. Assignment was random and double-blind.
Study · Free full text · about 8 min to read
Free full text on PubMed Central. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
In Iran, 39 male physical education students took 2 g of beta-alanine or dummy capsules a day for 6 weeks. Assignment was random and double-blind. All completed. Blood lactate after a graded cycling test was lower than with the dummy capsules. Oxygen uptake and time to exhaustion were compared only within groups. The paper contradicts itself on time to exhaustion. No one reported side effects. Funding: the Esfahan Sport Medicine Association; the authors report no conflicts of interest.
Recreationally active men did sprint training with beta-alanine or a dummy product; anaerobic working capacity differed, repeated sprints did not.
Trial · 11 and 10 on beta-alanine, 8 and 9 on the dummy product, randomized across two training conditions · 4 weeks · funding not stated
Wang et al., Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 2018
Terms and sources
- Recreationally active men
- 38 men, randomly assigned to four groups. Body measurements and blood measures did not change in any group.
- sprint training
- 8 sessions of repeated cycling sprints over 4 weeks. Half trained in air with 14.2% oxygen, half in normal air with 20.9%.
- beta-alanine
- 6.4 g a day for 4 weeks. The abstract does not name the form. Training volume and compliance did not differ between groups.
- a dummy product
- placebo; the abstract does not name its form. Groups had 11 and 10 men on beta-alanine and 8 and 9 on the dummy product.
- anaerobic working capacity differed
- After the intervention, it was higher in the beta-alanine groups than in the dummy-product groups. This main effect of the supplement was statistically significant. The abstract gives no numbers. The authors describe this as beta-alanine having maintained anaerobic working capacity.
- repeated sprints did not
- The authors report no added effect of beta-alanine on fatigue or repeated-sprint performance. Several aerobic and sprint measures were significantly higher in the groups that trained in air with less oxygen. We could not read the article's funding section.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Abstract only. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
38 recreationally active men were randomly assigned to beta-alanine or a dummy product. Each group trained in normal air or in air with less oxygen. Beta-alanine was 6.4 g a day for 4 weeks, with 8 cycling sprint sessions. Groups had 11 and 10 men on beta-alanine and 8 and 9 on the dummy product. After the intervention, anaerobic working capacity was higher with beta-alanine than with the dummy product. This difference was statistically significant. The authors report no added effect on fatigue or repeated sprints. Other differences followed the training condition. We read only the abstract. Funding: not checked.
Male cyclists took beta-alanine for 4 weeks; a short time trial did not differ from a dextrose dummy.
Trial · this comparison: 18 beta-alanine and 18 dummies only, of 71 randomized to four groups · 4 weeks
da Silva et al., Amino Acids, 2018
Terms and sources
- Male cyclists
- 71 male cyclists in Brazil in four groups. This comparison is the 18 with beta-alanine and the 18 with dummies only. Two other groups took sodium bicarbonate, alone or with beta-alanine.
- took beta-alanine
- 6.4 g a day for 28 days. Europe PMC lists FAPESP and CNPq grants as the funders.
- a short time trial
- A 30-kJ cycling time trial, 10 minutes after four 60-second bouts at 110% of maximal power.
- did not differ
- Time to complete the trial did not change significantly with any treatment. Beta-alanine did not change the estimated energy contribution of any system.
- a dextrose dummy
- placebo: dextrose in place of beta-alanine and calcium carbonate in place of bicarbonate. Assignment was random.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Abstract only. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
In Brazil, 71 male cyclists were randomly assigned to beta-alanine, sodium bicarbonate, both, or dummies only. Beta-alanine was 6.4 g a day for 28 days. This row compares the 18 on beta-alanine with the 18 on dummies only. Time in a short cycling time trial did not change significantly with any treatment. Beta-alanine did not change the estimated energy contribution of any system. We read only the abstract. Funding: Europe PMC lists FAPESP and CNPq grants as the funders.
Young men did interval cycling with beta-alanine or a dummy drink; fitness and work capacity did not differ.
Trial · 18 beta-alanine and 18 dummy drink; 46 men volunteered (a second report calls the other 10 a control group) · 6 weeks · industry-funded
Smith et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2009
Terms and sources
- Young men
- 46 recreationally active college men in the US; 18 took beta-alanine and 18 the dummy drink. A second report on the same men calls the other 10 a control group.
- interval cycling
- Three sessions a week of 2-minute bouts at 90–115% of peak power, for 6 weeks.
- beta-alanine
- 6 g a day for 3 weeks, then 3 g a day for 3 weeks, in a dextrose drink. The Results give 6.4 g a day for the first phase. FSI Nutrition and RunFast Promotions funded the study, per the article.
- a dummy drink
- placebo: the same dextrose drink without beta-alanine. Assignment was random and double-blind.
- did not differ
- Oxygen uptake, time to exhaustion, ventilatory threshold and total work did not differ between groups at any time. Lean mass rose only with beta-alanine; the paper gives no between-group test. The abstract describes changes within the beta-alanine group only. A second report on the same men found similar muscle fatigue changes in both groups (Smith et al., 2008).
Study · Free full text · about 21 min to read
Free full text on PubMed Central. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
In the US, recreationally active college men did 6 weeks of interval cycling. 18 took beta-alanine and 18 a dummy drink, assigned at random, double-blind. The dose was 6 g a day for 3 weeks, then 3 g. Oxygen uptake, time to exhaustion, ventilatory threshold and total work did not differ between groups. The abstract reports changes within the beta-alanine group. Funding: FSI Nutrition and RunFast Promotions; the authors report no competing interests.
Young men took beta-alanine for 8 weeks; muscle carnosine rose with it and did not change with a dummy product.
Trial · 31 randomized to three groups; the abstract does not give group sizes or how many completed · 8 weeks · industry co-funded
Stellingwerff et al., Amino Acids, 2011
Terms and sources
- Young men
- 31 young men, randomly assigned to three groups, double-blind. The authors worked at Nestlé Research Center and the University of Bern.
- took beta-alanine
- One group took 3.2 g a day for 4 weeks, then 1.6 g a day for 4 weeks. The other took 1.6 g a day for 8 weeks. The abstract does not name the form. Nestec Ltd. and the Swiss National Science Foundation funded the study. Two authors were Nestec employees, per the article.
- muscle carnosine rose
- Measured in two leg muscles by magnetic resonance at weeks 0, 2, 4, 8, 12 and 16. In the first 4 weeks, it rose 2.04 and 1.75 mmol/kg of wet muscle with 3.2 g a day. With 1.6 g a day, it rose 1.12 and 0.80 mmol/kg. After intake stopped, it fell by about 2% a week. The abstract calls flushing symptoms and blood chemistry "trivial in all three groups."
- did not change with a dummy product
- placebo; the abstract does not name its form. It reports no carnosine changes with the dummy product. It gives no test between groups.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Abstract only. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
31 young men were randomly assigned to two beta-alanine schedules or a dummy product, double-blind. One group took 3.2 g a day for 4 weeks, then 1.6 g for 4 weeks. The other took 1.6 g a day for 8 weeks. Muscle carnosine in two leg muscles was measured up to week 16. It rose in both beta-alanine groups and did not change with the dummy product. The abstract gives no test between groups. We read only the abstract. Funding: Nestec Ltd. and the Swiss National Science Foundation; two authors were Nestec employees.