In 51 trials in adults over 50, calcium supplements raised bone mineral density 0.7–1.8% more than comparison groups.
Review · in the 51 supplement trials · 12 weeks to 7 years
Tai et al., BMJ, 2015
Terms and sources
- calcium supplements
- 36 of the 51 trials gave calcium alone and 13 gave calcium with vitamin D; results were similar. Most trials used more than 500 mg a day. The review found no consistent difference between trials below and above 1,000 mg a day.
- bone mineral density
- Measured by bone scans (mostly DXA) at the spine, hip, forearm and whole body. The gain was there at 1 year and did not grow later.
- comparison groups
- a dummy pill (placebo) or no treatment
Study · Free full text · about 24 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
Researchers combined 51 randomized trials of calcium supplements in 12,257 adults over 50, most of them women. Most trials gave calcium alone; 13 added vitamin D. Comparison groups had a dummy pill or no treatment. Trials lasted 12 weeks to 7 years. Bone mineral density rose 0.7–1.8% more with calcium at the spine, hip, forearm and whole body. The gain appeared by 1 year and did not grow later. Results were similar with and without vitamin D. The authors describe the gains as small. Funding: Health Research Council of New Zealand. One author has received grants and fees from Merck, Amgen, Lilly and Novartis.
In 15 studies, about 20% more calcium was absorbed from calcium citrate than from calcium carbonate.
Review · 184 people · funding not stated
Sakhaee et al., American Journal of Therapeutics, 1999
Terms and sources
- 15 studies
- 184 people in all. The abstract does not say who took part or what doses they took.
- about 20% more
- 20.0% in all 15 studies; 27.2% on an empty stomach (5 studies) and 21.6% with meals (6 studies). The difference was statistically significant.
- funding not stated
- The PubMed record notes US government funding but does not name the funder. We could not open the full text.
Study · Access not checked · about 1 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers combined 15 published studies that measured calcium absorption from calcium citrate and calcium carbonate in 184 people. More calcium was absorbed from citrate: 20% more across all studies. On an empty stomach the gap was 27%; with meals, 22%. These differences were statistically significant. The abstract does not say who took part, what doses were used or how long the tests lasted. Health and symptoms were not measured. Funding: the PubMed record notes US government funding without naming the funder; we could not open the full text.
Women past menopause took single doses of carbonate or citrate products; blood calcium rose by the same amount.
Trial · 24 people · Single doses · funding not stated
Heaney et al., Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 2001
Terms and sources
- Women past menopause
- 24 women. All took a form of vitamin D (calcifediol) for a week before the tests.
- carbonate or citrate products
- A store-bought calcium carbonate, the same carbonate in plain capsules and a store-bought calcium citrate. Each woman had all three and a test without calcium, one after the other (crossover).
- blood calcium rose by the same amount
- Total blood calcium over 24 hours. Urine calcium rose slightly more with citrate; that difference was not statistically significant.
- funding not stated
- The PubMed record notes non-government funding but does not name the funder. We could not open the full text.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared store-bought calcium products in 24 women past menopause. Each woman had single doses of a calcium carbonate product, plain carbonate in capsules and a calcium citrate product. She also had one test day without calcium. Over 24 hours, blood calcium rose by the same amount with all three. Urine calcium rose slightly more with citrate, but not significantly. All women took a form of vitamin D for a week before testing. Health and symptoms were not measured. Funding: not named in the abstract; we could not open the full text.
Healthy adults ate crackers with coral calcium or calcium carbonate; more calcium appeared in urine after coral.
Trial · 12 people · 1 serving of each, 3 days apart · funding not stated
Ishitani et al., Journal of Nutritional Science and Vitaminology, 1999
Terms and sources
- coral calcium
- Coral powder from the Ryukyu Islands, about 20% calcium and 10% magnesium. Each cracker serving held 525 mg of calcium.
- calcium carbonate
- Crackers with the same 525 mg of calcium. Each person ate both, one after the other (crossover), 3 days apart.
- in urine
- Urine calcium is an indirect measure of absorption. The difference was statistically significant in the second half of the test period.
- funding not stated
- We could not find who paid for this study or supplied the product.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared calcium from coral with calcium carbonate in 12 healthy adults in Japan. Each person ate crackers with 525 mg of calcium from coral powder, and on another day crackers with calcium carbonate. The coral powder also held about 10% magnesium. After coral crackers, more calcium appeared in urine in the second half of the test period. The difference was statistically significant. Urine calcium is an indirect measure of absorption. Health and symptoms were not measured. Funding: not named in the abstract; we could not open the full text.
Cyclists took calcium before riding; blood calcium fell less than with a dummy chew, a bone marker did not differ.
Trial · 51 people · 1 dose before 1 ride · maker-supplied
Sherk et al., Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2017
Terms and sources
- Cyclists took calcium
- 51 competitive male cyclists aged 18–45. 1,000 mg of calcium itself as chewable calcium citrate, 30 minutes before a simulated 35-km time trial in the lab.
- blood calcium fell less
- Ionized calcium in serum; the difference was statistically significant. A hormone that draws calcium from bone (PTH) rose less, but not significantly.
- a dummy chew
- placebo chew, taken 30 minutes before the same ride
- a bone marker
- CTX, a marker of bone breakdown, rose by the same amount in both groups.
- maker-supplied
- Marigot Ltd (Cork, Ireland) provided the calcium and dummy products. US National Institutes of Health grants paid for the study in part. The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Study · Free full text · about 14 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
Researchers tested calcium taken just before hard exercise in 51 competitive male cyclists. Thirty minutes before a 35-km ride, half chewed 1,000 mg of calcium as citrate. The other half had a dummy chew. Blood calcium fell in both groups during the ride, but less with calcium. That difference was statistically significant. A hormone that draws calcium from bone rose less, but not significantly. A marker of bone breakdown rose the same in both groups. Ride times did not differ significantly. Funding: US government grants in part; Marigot Ltd provided the calcium and dummy products.