Protein is a nutrient built from amino acids. Meat, fish, eggs, dairy foods, beans and nuts supply it in the diet. Protein supplements are mostly powders of milk proteins, whey and casein, or of plant proteins such as soy and pea.
Protein in the body
The body uses protein to build, maintain and repair muscle. Proteins are made of amino acids. Nine of them are called essential, because they must come from the diet. Most complete proteins are about 40% essential amino acids, so 25 g of protein gives about 10 g.
Terms and sources
- build, maintain and repair muscle
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- Nine of them
- Histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan and valine. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- complete proteins
- Proteins that contain all nine essential amino acids. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
Exercise increases the breakdown of muscle protein. Afterwards, muscle protein building stays higher for up to a day or two. Regular strength training adds protein to muscle fibers, and the fibers grow larger. Aerobic exercise adds less protein, mainly in mitochondria, the parts of cells that use oxygen.
Terms and sources
- breakdown of muscle protein
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- muscle protein building
- muscle protein synthesis. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
Human muscle protein is 38% essential amino acids and 7.6% leucine. Laboratories usually estimate protein from nitrogen: the nitrogen content times 6.25.
Terms and sources
- 38%
- Measured in muscle samples from 10 volunteers, as a reference for protein powders. Gorissen et al., Amino Acids, 2018.
- times 6.25
- The standard nitrogen-to-protein factor; factors specific to each source are known for only some proteins. Gorissen et al., Amino Acids, 2018.
Where protein comes from
Meats, poultry, seafood, eggs, dairy products, beans and nuts contain protein. Casein is the main protein of milk, and whey is another. Adding acid to milk makes casein clump and settle, while whey stays in the liquid. The proteins are then filtered to remove lactose and fat.
Terms and sources
- contain protein
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- main protein of milk
- NIH calls casein "the main complete protein in milk." NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- whey is another
- NIH calls whey one of the complete proteins isolated from milk. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- Adding acid
- International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2017.
- filtered
- Ion exchange or membrane filtration. International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2017.
Most protein powders and drinks contain whey, according to NIH. Plant protein isolates are made from soy, pea, brown rice, hemp, potato, wheat, oat and other crops. For one pea isolate, peas were ground into flour, the starch and fiber were removed, and the protein was dried.
Terms and sources
- according to NIH
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- Plant protein isolates
- Plant sources among 35 commercial protein powders tested in one lab study. Gorissen et al., Amino Acids, 2018.
- one pea isolate
- The isolate used in a trial below held 85% protein. Babault et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2015.
Daily amounts and the upper limit
NIH notes that the Food and Nutrition Board "has not set a UL for protein, noting that the risk of adverse effects from excess protein from food is very low." NIH adds: "However, it advises caution for those obtaining high protein intakes from foods and supplements because of the limited data on their potential adverse effects." According to NIH, high-protein diets "do not appear to increase the risk of renal stones or dehydration; compromise renal function; reduce bone health; or, when consumed for several months, alter glomerular filtration rate or blood levels of lipids, glucose, creatine, or blood urea nitrogen." NIH notes: "Protein increases urinary calcium excretion, but this appears to have no consequence for long-term bone health and, in any event, is easily compensated for by the consumption of slightly more calcium." The NIH summary table lists "No safety concerns reported at daily recommended intakes for athletes of up to about 2.0 g/kg body weight (e.g., 136 g for a person weighing 150 lb)," with reported adverse effects "None known."
Terms and sources
- Food and Nutrition Board
- The Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academies, which sets US Dietary Reference Intakes. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- high-protein diets
- NIH gives as an example diets with two to three times the RDA. The RDA is 0.8 g per kg a day for healthy adults.
- The NIH summary table
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
United States
The RDA for protein is 0.8 g per kg of body weight a day for healthy adults. For an adult weighing 70 kg (154 lb), that is 56 g a day. The National Academies have not set an upper limit for protein. NIH reports a national survey of US adults. Men ate an average of 100 g of protein a day, and women 69 g.
Terms and sources
- RDA
- Recommended Dietary Allowance, set by the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academies. It is 0.85 g per kg for adolescents. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
- 56 g
- Our estimate: 0.8 × 70.
- upper limit
- Basis, as NIH summarizes the National Academies: a very low risk of adverse effects from excess protein from food. NIH's full words are above.
- a national survey
- National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
NIH notes that more recent data suggest athletes need 1.2–2.0 g per kg a day.
Terms and sources
- more recent data
- Data published after the RDA was set, cited by NIH from sports nutrition organizations. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, exercise and athletic performance fact sheet.
In the NIH label database, 3,259 US labels list grams of protein and name a protein source; 94% are powders. Whey is named on 55% of them and a plant protein on 37%. Of the 1,790 whey labels, 64% name isolate, 38% concentrate and 24% hydrolyzed whey. In the same database, 1,173 more labels list grams of protein and name collagen as the only source. They are not in these counts.
Terms and sources
- 3,259 US labels
- NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database, including products no longer sold. Labels with a Protein row above 0 g. They name whey, casein, milk protein, egg, beef or bone broth, or a plant protein. Labels whose only source is collagen are not counted, including bone broth named as collagen. Colostrum whey is not counted either. We counted these.
- 55%
- 1,790 labels name whey and 1,222 a plant protein; 71 (2%) name both a milk protein and a plant protein. We counted these.
- 64% name isolate
- A label can name more than one. 18% name none of the three. We counted these.
- 1,173 more labels
- The same Protein row, with collagen named and none of the sources above. We counted these.
Powders with whey as the only protein list a middle half of 20–25 g of protein per serving. Pea-only powders list a middle half of 14–20 g, and plant blends 18–22 g. On 2,871 labels with a serving weight in grams, protein is a middle half of 44–74% of that weight. 507 labels list leucine, with a middle half of 1.6–6.2 g per serving.
Terms and sources
- a middle half of 20–25 g
- 1,193 powder labels; the middle value is 24 g. A serving is not always a full day's amount.
- Pea-only powders
- 237 pea-only and 708 plant-blend powder labels. Soy-only powders: 29 labels, 9.5–15 g.
- 44–74%
- The middle value is 64%: 72% for whey only, 54% for plant blends, 53% for pea only. 98 labels listing more protein than the serving weight were set aside. We counted these.
- 507 labels list leucine
- Rows named leucine or L-leucine, from an amino acid list or added leucine. We counted these.
US rules require a notice on protein products that get more than half of their calories from protein. The required wording is: "Notice: Use this product as a food supplement only. Do not use for weight reduction." Such products sold for weight reduction must carry this warning instead: "WARNING: Very low calorie protein diets (below 400 Calories per day) may cause serious illness or death. Do Not Use for Weight Reduction in Such Diets Without Medical Supervision. Not for use by infants, children, or pregnant or nursing women." In our count, 849 of the 3,259 labels carry a version of the first notice; 761 carry it in full.
Terms and sources
- US rules
- FDA rule 21 CFR 101.17(d)(3). Scope: supplementation products with "more than 50 percent of their total caloric value" from protein, its hydrolysates or amino acids. It applies when they are sold for purposes other than weight reduction. The notice must appear prominently on the principal display panel.
- sold for weight reduction
- 21 CFR 101.17(d)(1). Products in a balanced diet plan of 400 or more Calories a day carry another notice, under (d)(2).
- 849 of the 3,259 labels
- Labels in the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database. A version: the words "do not use for weight reduction," without the warning above. In full: both sentences of the notice. 11 labels carry the weight-reduction warning. The rule depends on the share of calories from protein. Our count does not check that share. We counted these.
Published studies of protein
3 studies in adults without a diagnosis: 1 found a difference, 2 found none.
Not shown: trials in frail older adults and in older adults chosen for low muscle mass and function. The second also used vitamin D and extra leucine. Also not shown: a vegan and meat-eater comparison without random groups. Also not shown: a review of 49 trials. It included older adults in care homes and supplements with added vitamins. A review of 22 trials that included frail older adults is not shown either. Nor is a review whose trial list we could not check. A study of 18 men is not shown: its abstract does not say how they were assigned to groups.
Our one-line summary comes first. The original is on PubMed.
Show the 3 studies
Healthy adults over 65 took whey twice daily for a year; muscle size and strength did not differ from carbohydrate.
Trial · 208 randomized to 5 groups; group sizes not in the abstract · 1 year · industry author
Mertz et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2021
Terms and sources
- Healthy adults over 65
- 208 people randomized to 5 groups; 184 completed. The abstract does not give the size of each group.
- took whey twice daily
- 20 g of whey protein with 10 g of carbohydrate per serving, without exercise training. The comparison group took 30 g of carbohydrate per serving. A collagen group also did not differ from it.
- muscle size and strength
- Thigh muscle area, the main outcome, plus leg strength and power, function and body composition: no measure differed. Heavy strength training with whey kept thigh muscle and increased strength, compared with whey alone. Light training with whey increased knee strength compared with whey alone, but not thigh muscle.
- industry author
- One author works at Arla Foods Ingredients. We could not read the funding section or who made the products.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We have not checked whether the full text is free.
Study summary
This trial randomized 208 healthy adults over 65 to five groups for one year. One group took 20 g of whey protein twice daily without exercise training. A comparison group took carbohydrate instead, and another took collagen. Thigh muscle area, leg strength, function and body composition did not differ between whey and carbohydrate. Heavy strength training with whey kept thigh muscle and increased strength, compared with whey alone. Light training with whey increased knee strength, but not thigh muscle. 184 people finished. Funding: not read; one author works at Arla Foods Ingredients.
Young men in strength training gained more strength and thigh muscle with a bedtime protein drink than a dummy drink.
Trial · 44 people · 12 weeks · industry author
Snijders et al., Journal of Nutrition, 2015
Terms and sources
- Young men in strength training
- 44 men, mean age 22, in a 12-week progressive program.
- a bedtime protein drink
- 27.5 g of protein with 15 g of carbohydrate every night before sleep. The International Society of Sports Nutrition describes it as casein.
- more strength
- Total gain in maximal lifts: 164 kg versus 130 kg; statistically significant.
- thigh muscle
- Quadriceps area rose 8.4 versus 4.8 cm²; type II muscle fibers also grew more. Both statistically significant.
- a dummy drink
- A placebo without calories; the protein drink also gave carbohydrate and energy.
- industry author
- One author works at DSM Biotechnology Center. We could not read the funding section.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We have not checked whether the full text is free.
Study summary
This trial randomized 44 healthy young men to a 12-week strength-training program. Every night before sleep, one group drank 27.5 g of protein with 15 g of carbohydrate. The other drank a dummy drink without calories. Total gains in maximal lifts were 164 kg versus 130 kg. Thigh muscle area rose 8.4 versus 4.8 cm², and type II fibers grew more. All three differences were statistically significant. The comparison drink gave no energy. Funding: not read; one author works at DSM.
Biceps thickness and strength did not differ among pea, whey and a dummy powder in 161 men training 12 weeks.
Trial · 161 randomized, 137 analyzed · 12 weeks · maker-funded
Babault et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2015
Terms and sources
- Biceps thickness
- Measured by ultrasound. Gains: whey 15.3%, pea 13.4%, dummy powder 10.7%; not statistically significant. In the 68 weakest men at the start, pea gained more than the dummy powder. Whey did not differ from either. The abstract's conclusion on pea comes from this subgroup.
- strength
- Arm-curl maximum and torque on a dynamometer rose in all groups, with no difference between groups.
- pea, whey
- 25 g twice a day of pea protein isolate (NUTRALYS) or whey protein concentrate, as a cocoa drink.
- a dummy powder
- A placebo of maltodextrin with the same flavor and the same calories.
- 161 men
- Aged 18–35, active but not strength training before. 137 finished. Adverse events: 3 with whey, 4 with the dummy powder, 1 with pea; the authors relate most to usual activity.
- maker-funded
- Roquette paid for the study. Three authors work at Roquette. The article lists NUTRALYS pea protein under Roquette's name.
Study · Free full text · about 20 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text without tables.
Study summary
This trial randomized 161 active men aged 18 to 35 to 12 weeks of arm strength training. They drank 25 g of pea protein, whey protein or a dummy powder twice a day. Biceps thickness rose in all groups: 13.4% with pea, 15.3% with whey and 10.7% with the dummy powder. The difference was not statistically significant. Strength rose alike in all groups. Among the weakest 68 men, pea gained more than the dummy powder. 137 men finished. Funding: Roquette, named in the article with the pea protein, paid for the study; three authors work there.
Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.