6,377 older women took 600 IU of vitamin E every other day or dummy pills; thinking-test scores did not differ.
Trial · women in the thinking-test substudy; randomized in the parent trial · Up to 9.6 years · funding not stated
Kang et al., Arch Intern Med, 2006
Terms and sources
- 6,377 older women
- Generally healthy US women aged 65 and over, in part of the Women's Health Study. Tests were done by telephone every 2 years.
- 600 IU of vitamin E
- Alpha-tocopherol acetate on alternate days. The trial's main report names natural-source vitamin E: 402 mg by the NIH conversion (our estimate).
- thinking-test scores did not differ
- General thinking, verbal memory and naming words in a category, combined into one score. No difference at 5.6 or 9.6 years. Change over time and the risk of a large decline did not differ either. An editorial on this trial was also published; we could not read it.
- funding not stated
- First author at Channing Laboratory, Boston. PubMed tags NIH grants. We could not read the funding section or who made the capsules.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate: abstract only, about 2 minutes.
Study summary
6,377 generally healthy women aged 65 and over took part in thinking tests within the Women's Health Study. They took 600 IU of vitamin E every other day or dummy pills. Tests of general thinking, verbal memory and naming words were done by telephone every 2 years. Combined scores did not differ between the groups at 5.6 or 9.6 years. Change over time was also similar. Source: PubMed abstract (PMID 17159011). Funding: not stated in the abstract.
455 inactive adults exercised with 800 IU vitamin E or dummy capsules; blood fats and markers did not differ.
Trial · randomized: 227 vitamin E, 228 dummy capsules (Table 1A); 380 still in the study at week 4 · 8 weeks
Garelnabi et al., NMCD, 2011
Terms and sources
- 455 inactive adults
- Sedentary adults aged 18–55 who did not take supplements; people with listed conditions and smokers were excluded. 227 were assigned vitamin E and 228 dummy capsules.
- 800 IU vitamin E
- Two 400 IU soft gels a day with meals; one sentence of the paper says 400 IU a day. The paper calls it alpha-tocopherol of full biological potency and does not name the form. 800 IU is 536 mg if natural, 360 mg if synthetic, by the NIH conversions (our estimate). Capsules came from J.R. Carlson Laboratories; the paper does not say whether they were bought.
- blood fats and markers did not differ
- Markers of oxidation and inflammation: no statistically significant differences between the groups; the authors describe trends only. Fitness rose in both sexes. The paper does not compare fitness after 8 weeks between the groups.
Study · Free full text · about 13 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
455 sedentary adults aged 18 to 55 began 8 weeks of aerobic exercise. 227 took 800 IU of vitamin E a day and 228 took dummy capsules. The paper does not name the form of vitamin E. Blood fats and markers of oxidation and inflammation showed no statistically significant differences between the groups. Fitness, measured as peak oxygen uptake, rose in both sexes. The paper does not compare fitness after 8 weeks between the groups. Source: PMC full text (PMID 21782401). Funding: grants from the US National Institutes of Health (NHLBI).
Adults took 400 IU of natural vitamin E or a dummy pill for 2 months; blood gamma-tocopherol fell 58%.
Trial · randomized in the whole trial; the abstract does not give the number per comparison · 2 months · funding not stated
Huang and Appel, J Nutr, 2003
Terms and sources
- Adults
- 184 non-smoking adults. The trial also tested vitamin C. The abstract does not say how the group taking both vitamins is counted here.
- 400 IU of natural vitamin E
- RRR-alpha-tocopheryl acetate a day: 268 mg of alpha-tocopherol by the NIH conversion (our estimate).
- fell 58%
- Median change compared with the dummy pill; statistically significant. Fewer people had measurable delta-tocopherol. Gamma- and delta-tocopherol are other forms of vitamin E in food.
- funding not stated
- Authors at Johns Hopkins University. PubMed tags US Public Health Service grants; we could not read the funding section.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate: abstract only, about 2 minutes.
Study summary
184 non-smoking adults joined a 2-month trial. Some took 400 IU of natural vitamin E acetate a day, others a dummy pill. Compared with the dummy pill, blood gamma-tocopherol fell by a median 58%. This is another form of vitamin E from food. The difference was statistically significant. Fewer people had measurable delta-tocopherol. The trial also tested vitamin C, and the abstract does not say how the group taking both vitamins was counted. Source: PubMed abstract (PMID 14519797). Funding: not stated in the abstract.
Ten men took natural and synthetic vitamin E in random order; natural-form blood levels were about 33% higher.
Trial · 10 people · Two 4-week periods, 12 weeks apart · funding not stated
Proteggente et al., J Nutr, 2005
Terms and sources
- Ten men
- Healthy men who carry the apoE4 gene variant, a group the authors chose. Each took both forms in turn, one after the other, 12 weeks apart.
- natural and synthetic vitamin E
- A labeled 150 mg dose of RRR- or all-rac-alpha-tocopheryl acetate. It was given before and after 4 weeks of 400 mg a day.
- about 33% higher
- Ratios 1.35 (peak) and 1.33 (area under the curve). The abstract calls 1.36 the accepted ratio; IU were based on it. The abstract does not say whether the difference was statistically significant. Acuff 1994, below, found about double when both forms were taken together.
- funding not stated
- PubMed lists only the first author's affiliation, University of Surrey, and tags non-government grants. We could not read the funding section.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate: abstract only, about 2 minutes.
Study summary
Ten healthy men who carry the apoE4 gene variant took natural and synthetic vitamin E acetate in random order. Each form was given at 400 mg a day for 4 weeks, 12 weeks apart. Before and after each period, they took a labeled 150 mg dose. Blood levels of the natural form were about 33% higher. The ratios were 1.33 to 1.35. The abstract calls 1.36 the accepted ratio; IU were based on it. The abstract does not state statistical significance for the ratio. Source: PubMed abstract (PMID 15867282). Funding: not stated in the abstract.
Six adults took equal natural and synthetic vitamin E together for 11 days; natural-form blood levels were about double.
Trial · 6 people · 11 days; blood followed to day 137 · funding not stated
Acuff et al., Am J Clin Nutr, 1994
Terms and sources
- Six adults
- 3 men and 3 women aged 25–59. Every person took both forms at the same time, so there was no dummy pill.
- natural and synthetic vitamin E
- 150 mg each of RRR- and all-rac-alpha-tocopheryl acetate a day. Each carried a different heavy-hydrogen label, so both were measured in the same blood.
- about double
- Ratio of the areas under the blood curves 2.0, statistically significant; the same after adjusting for blood fats. Proteggente 2005, above, gave the forms separately and found about 1.33. A letter on this study was published. We could not read it.
- funding not stated
- The abstract does not say who paid. PubMed lists only the first author's affiliation, East Tennessee State University.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate: abstract only, about 2 minutes.
Study summary
Six adults aged 25 to 59 took 150 mg each of natural and synthetic vitamin E acetate for 11 days. Each form carried a different heavy-hydrogen label, so both could be measured in the same blood. Blood held about double the natural form: a ratio of 2.0, statistically significant. Adjusting for blood fats gave the same result. Every person took both forms, so there was no dummy pill. Source: PubMed abstract (PMID 8074072). Funding: not stated in the abstract.