In 218 young adults, knee pain during sport fell more with 5 g collagen peptides daily than a dummy powder.
Trial · Randomized; 180 finished and were analyzed per protocol. · 12 weeks · maker-funded
Zdzieblik et al., Nutrients, 2021
Terms and sources
- 218 young adults
- Aged 18–30, active more than 3 hours a week, with knee pain linked to activity and no knee diagnosis.
- knee pain during sport
- On a 100 mm scale it fell by 21.9 mm with collagen and 15.6 mm with the dummy powder. The physician's rating agreed. Both differences were statistically significant.
- 5 g collagen peptides
- Fortigel, porcine type I collagen peptides of about 3 kDa, from GELITA. Pain at rest and after squats did not differ.
- a dummy powder
- placebo: maltodextrin, a starch powder
- maker-funded
- GELITA, the maker of Fortigel, provided the peptides and paid for part of the study. GELITA partly paid for lectures by one author.
Study · Free full text · about 18 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the full text on PubMed Central.
Study summary
The trial compared 5 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy powder for 12 weeks. It included 218 active adults aged 18–30 with knee pain during sport. People with a diagnosed knee condition were excluded. On a 100 mm scale, pain during activity fell by 21.9 mm with collagen. It fell by 15.6 mm with the dummy powder. The difference was statistically significant, and the physician's rating agreed. Pain at rest and after squats did not differ. Funding: in part by GELITA, which also provided the peptides.
Pain at rest and walking fell more with 5 g collagen peptides daily than a dummy powder in 182 adults.
Trial · Randomized; 154 finished and were analyzed. · 12 weeks · maker-supplied
Schulze et al., International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2024
Terms and sources
- Pain at rest and walking
- As rated by a physician; both differences were statistically significant. The physician's rating on stairs did not differ significantly. Joint stiffness did not differ.
- 5 g collagen peptides
- Fortigel, porcine type I collagen peptides of about 3 kDa, from GELITA, mixed with 5 g of maltodextrin.
- a dummy powder
- placebo: 10 g of maltodextrin
- maker-supplied
- GELITA provided the Fortigel peptides. GELITA partly paid for lectures by one author, who also co-invented patents on collagen peptides.
- 182 adults
- Healthy adults over 18 with knee or hip pain in daily life. Participants also rated pain on stairs and when kneeling, and restriction when squatting, lower with collagen.
Study · Free full text · about 16 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the full text on PubMed Central.
Study summary
The trial compared 5 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy powder for 12 weeks. It included 182 healthy adults with knee or hip pain during daily activities; 154 finished. A physician rated pain at rest and during walking. Both fell more with collagen, and the differences were statistically significant. Participants rated pain on stairs and when kneeling, and restriction when squatting, lower with collagen. The physician's rating on stairs did not differ significantly. Joint stiffness did not differ. Funding: GELITA provided the peptides; one author co-invented patents on collagen peptides.
Knee pain and function scores did not differ between 10 g collagen peptides and a dummy product in 167 adults.
Trial · 167 people · 12 weeks · funding not stated
Bongers et al., Applied Physiology, Nutrition, and Metabolism, 2020
Terms and sources
- Knee pain and function scores
- A pain scale and two knee questionnaires. Scores changed by similar amounts in both groups. Blood markers of cartilage, bone and inflammation did not differ either.
- 10 g collagen peptides
- A day, for 12 weeks. The abstract does not name the product or its source.
- a dummy product
- placebo; the abstract does not describe it
- 167 adults
- Healthy and physically active, median age 63, with self-reported knee pain.
Study · Access not checked · about 1 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We have not checked whether the full text is free.
Study summary
The trial compared 10 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy product for 12 weeks. It included 167 healthy, physically active adults, median age 63, with self-reported knee pain. Knee pain scores fell by 1.6 points with collagen and by 1.9 with the dummy product. The difference was not statistically significant. Two knee questionnaires rose by similar amounts in both groups. Blood markers of cartilage, bone and inflammation did not differ. Funding: not stated in the sources we could read.
In 86 active adults aged 40–65, daily-activity scores differed with collagen, but knee pain scores did not overall.
Trial · Randomized; 59 were analyzed at 6 months and 41 at 9 months. · 6–9 months · maker-funded
Kviatkovsky et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2023
Terms and sources
- 86 active adults aged 40–65
- Lifelong exercisers with joint or muscle pain and no diagnosed joint condition.
- daily-activity scores
- From a knee questionnaire, at 6 months. The groups changed differently over time, but no single group changed significantly. The abstract reports this as a gain with 10 g. A physical health score also changed differently between groups over 9 months; no single group changed significantly.
- with collagen
- 10 g or 20 g of SOLUGEL collagen peptides a day, versus a dummy powder (placebo: maltodextrin).
- maker-funded
- PB Leiner, part of Tessenderlo Group, paid for the study and provided its SOLUGEL collagen peptides.
- knee pain scores did not
- They differed only among people who exercise at least 188 minutes a week. People injured during the study were removed before the groups were revealed.
Study · Free full text · about 23 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the full text on PubMed Central.
Study summary
The trial compared 10 g or 20 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy powder. It included 86 lifelong exercisers aged 40–65 with joint or muscle pain; 59 were analyzed at 6 months. Scores for daily activities changed differently between groups over 6 months. No single group changed significantly in follow-up tests. Knee pain scores did not differ overall. They differed only in people who exercise at least 188 minutes a week. A physical health score also changed differently between groups over 9 months; no single group changed significantly. People injured during the study were left out of the analysis. Funding: PB Leiner, the maker of the tested peptides.
With strength training, tendon size grew more with 5 g collagen peptides in 50 men; strength did not differ.
Trial · 50 completed; the abstract does not give the number randomized. · 14 weeks · funding not stated
Jerger et al., European Journal of Sport Science, 2023
Terms and sources
- tendon size
- Cross-section of the kneecap tendon at 60% and 70% of its length. The difference was statistically significant. Tendon stiffness did not differ.
- 5 g collagen peptides
- Specific collagen peptides, daily for 14 weeks, versus the same amount of a dummy product (placebo).
- 50 men
- Healthy and moderately active, training the thigh muscles 3 times a week.
- strength did not differ
- Strength and thigh muscle size rose in both groups by similar amounts.
Study · Access not checked · about 1 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We have not checked whether the full text is free.
Study summary
The trial compared 5 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy product during 14 weeks of strength training. It included 50 healthy, moderately active men. The kneecap tendon grew more in cross-section with collagen, at 60% and 70% of its length. That difference was statistically significant. Tendon stiffness, thigh muscle size and strength rose in both groups and did not differ. Women were not studied. Funding: not stated in the sources we could read.
In 39 training young men, tendon size and stiffness did not differ between 15 g collagen and a dummy product.
Trial · 39 people · 15 weeks · funding not stated
Balshaw et al., Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 2023
Terms and sources
- 39 training young men
- Healthy and recreationally active, doing leg strength training 3 times a week for 15 weeks.
- tendon size and stiffness
- Of the kneecap tendon, measured by MRI and during knee extensions. Stiffness rose by 17.3% with collagen and 20.9% with the dummy product.
- 15 g collagen
- Specific collagen peptides, once a day. The abstract does not name the product or its source.
- a dummy product
- placebo; the abstract does not describe it
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. The full text is behind a subscription.
Study summary
The trial compared 15 g of collagen peptides a day with a dummy product for 15 weeks. It included 39 healthy, recreationally active young men doing leg strength training. Researchers measured the kneecap tendon by MRI and its stiffness during knee extensions. No measure of tendon size or stiffness differed between the groups. Tendon stiffness rose by 17.3% with collagen and by 20.9% with the dummy product. Women and older adults were not studied. Funding: not stated in the sources we could read.