Citrucel or Metamucil: what does the ingredient change?

Citrucel contains methylcellulose, a fiber made from cellulose, and Metamucil contains psyllium husk, a fiber from a plant seed; both are sold as bulk-forming fiber laxatives.[1][2] Methylcellulose is viscous without forming a gel. The maker's excess-gas statement is based on laboratory testing. Psyllium forms a gel and is partly fermented.[3][4][5]

Two US products, side by side

Label comparisonCitrucel Orange Mix powderCitrucel capletsMetamucil Sugar-Free Orange packets
Fiber ingredientMethylcellulose[1]Methylcellulose[5]Psyllium husk[2]
Amount per unit2 g per heaping tablespoon[1]500 mg per caplet[5]About 3.4 g psyllium husk per packet[2]
Calories60, from sucrose and maltodextrin[1]—[5]—[2]
Minerals listedCalcium 80 mg, potassium 105 mg, sodium 10 mg per heaping tablespoon[1]Calcium 10 mg per caplet[5]Sodium 5 mg and potassium 30 mg per packet[2]
Adult directionsStart with 1 heaping tablespoon; increase as needed up to 3 times a day[1]Start with 2 caplets. Up to 6 doses a day, no more than 12 caplets.[6]1 packet at the first sign of irregularity, up to 3 times a day[2]
FluidAt least 8 oz of liquid. Stir briskly and drink promptly.[1]At least 8 oz of water or other fluid[5]At least 8 oz of water or other fluid[2]

The table compares the Drug Facts for three specific presentations. A dash means that the source used for that presentation did not give a value for the row.[1][2][5]

Retail prices vary with pack size and store, and the products are sold in different forms and sizes.

What the ingredient changes

Gel and water. Psyllium forms a thick gel that holds water in the gut; methylcellulose is viscous but does not form that kind of gel.[3] In a trial on MRI, 22 healthy adults drank 15 g of inulin with 15 g of psyllium, methylcellulose or a placebo powder; both fibers raised water in the small bowel and colon, and methylcellulose raised it more.[7]

Gas. Citrucel's label states that it won't cause excess gas, based on laboratory testing.[5] In the MRI trial, breath hydrogen, a sign of gas from fermentation, did not differ between the three drinks over 24 hours.[7] In a second trial with the same design, 30 healthy adults completed all periods; psyllium lowered breath hydrogen from inulin over the first 6 hours and slowed its arrival in the large intestine compared with methylcellulose and placebo.[8]

These trials used methylcellulose and psyllium as test ingredients; they did not test Citrucel or Metamucil as sold.[7][8]

Using either product

  • Choking. The Drug Facts for the two Citrucel forms and the Metamucil packets warn that taking them without enough fluid can block the throat. They say not to take them if you have difficulty swallowing.[1][2][5]
  • Medicines. The Metamucil packet label advises taking it at least 2 hours before or after other medicines.[2]
  • When to ask a doctor. The Citrucel label advises asking a doctor before use if bowel habits change suddenly for two weeks or with abdominal pain, nausea or vomiting, and stopping if constipation lasts more than 7 days or there is rectal bleeding.[5]

The fiber guide explains soluble, gel-forming and fermentable fiber, and the page on Metamucil and Benefiber compares psyllium with wheat dextrin.

Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.

Sources

  1. Citrucel Orange Mix Fiber Powder, Drug Facts (PDF). https://www.vitalitymedical.com/pdf/assets-2/drug-facts-citrucel-orange-mix-fiber-powder.pdf — methylcellulose 2 g per heaping tablespoon, bulk-forming fiber laxative; calcium 80 mg, potassium 105 mg, sodium 10 mg; 60 calories from sucrose and maltodextrin; adults start with 1 heaping tablespoon, increase as needed up to 3 times per day. ↩
  2. Procter & Gamble. Metamucil Therapy for Regularity, sugar-free orange packets, NDC 37000-024. DailyMed Drug Facts, directions, warnings and other information. Each 5.8 g packet lists about 3.4 g of psyllium husk. https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/drugInfo.cfm?setid=a9824f73-5ea2-4a65-a926-3a57561441b8 ↩
  3. McRorie JW. Cereal Foods World, May–June 2020. https://cerealsgrains.org/publications/cfw/2020/May-June/Pages/CFW-65-3-0028.aspx — methylcellulose as a viscous, non-gel-forming fiber; psyllium as gel-forming. text in search results. The author's affiliation was not checked. ↩
  4. Marteau P, and colleagues. Gut. 1994. https://doi.org/10.1136/gut.35.12.1747 — PubMed 7829013. About 24% of psyllium arabinose and 53% of xylose were fermented. abstract. Funding: not stated in the abstract. ↩
  5. Citrucel with SmartFiber caplets, Drug Facts as transcribed by Giant. https://giantfoodstores.com/groceries/health-beauty/digestive-health-nausea/citrucel-with-smartfiber-fiber-orange-caplets-100-ct-btl.html — methylcellulose 500 mg per caplet; calcium 10 mg; choking warning; at least 8 oz of fluid; "won't cause excess gas" based on laboratory testing. ↩
  6. Citrucel caplets, DailyMed Drug Facts, Directions. Adult starting dose and daily caplet limit. https://dailymed.nlm.nih.gov/dailymed/drugInfo.cfm?setid=d27f6742-2dcc-451e-b803-6ffe183038ec ↩
  7. Dellschaft and colleagues. Alimentary Pharmacology and Therapeutics. 2026. https://doi.org/10.1111/apt.70964 — PubMed 42728685. Randomized crossover; 22 healthy adults. abstract. Funding: not checked. ↩
  8. Reid and colleagues. Food and Function. 2026. https://doi.org/10.1039/d5fo03532e — PubMed 41636227. Randomized single-blind crossover; 41 randomized, 30 analyzed. full text. Funding: UK Medical Research Council, NIHR and BBSRC; two authors report industry grants or consulting. ↩

You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.