Metamucil or Benefiber: is it the same fiber?

Metamucil contains psyllium husk, which forms a gel. Benefiber Original contains wheat dextrin, which dissolves without thickening.[1][2][3] For the US labels below, a rounded teaspoon of Metamucil lists 3 g of fiber. Benefiber's current four-teaspoon serving lists 6 g.[1][2]

Two US powders, side by side

Per label amountMetamucil 4-in-1 Sugar-Free Orange Smooth, 23.3 ozBenefiber Original Prebiotic Fiber Supplement, Unflavored
Amount shown1 rounded teaspoon, 5.8 g[1]4 teaspoons[2]
Fiber ingredientPsyllium husk[1]Wheat dextrin[2]
Dietary fiber3 g, 11% of the Daily Value[1]6 g, 21% of the Daily Value[2]
Soluble fiber2 g[1]—[2]
Calories15[1]—[2]
Total carbohydrate5 g[1]—[2]
Other ingredientsMaltodextrin, citric acid, natural and artificial orange flavor, aspartame, Yellow 6[1]None listed[2]
Mix with8 oz or more of cool liquid[4]4–8 oz of a non-carbonated drink or soft food[2]
Adult label directions for digestive health1 rounded teaspoon up to 3 times a day[4]4 teaspoons once a day[2]

The Metamucil figures use the one-teaspoon column of the archived label for the 23.3 oz canister. The Benefiber figures use the manufacturer’s current four-teaspoon serving. A dash means the manufacturer text consulted did not give a value for that row.[1][2]

Retail prices vary with pack size and store, and the two products are sold in different sizes.

What the kind of fiber changes

Psyllium is a soluble fiber that forms a thick gel; most of it reaches the large intestine intact and keeps holding water there.[3][5] Wheat dextrin is soluble and non-viscous: it dissolves clear and does not form a gel.[2][3] A review of isolated fibers groups wheat dextrin with inulin as non-viscous fibers and psyllium with beta-glucan as gel-forming fibers.[3]

What has been compared

The sources checked for this page include no trial that compared the two products. Trials of psyllium in healthy adults measured stool weight, water in the colon and gas (see the psyllium page).[5] A label comparison shows the grams of fiber and the ingredients; which product works better for a given purpose is a question for trials.

Using either product

  • Fluid. Bulk-forming fiber taken with too little fluid can swell and cause choking; the Metamucil label asks for 8 oz or more of liquid and says to avoid the product if you have difficulty swallowing.[4]
  • Starting. The Metamucil label advises new users to start with one serving a day and increase gradually; minor bloating can occur.[4]
  • Medicines. The Metamucil label advises taking it at least 2 hours before or after medicines.[4]
  • Phenylketonuria. The sugar-free Metamucil contains aspartame and lists 25 mg of phenylalanine per teaspoon.[4]
  • Wheat. The manufacturer identifies wheat dextrin as the ingredient and says the wheat is processed to meet FDA's gluten-free requirements.[2]

The fiber guide explains soluble, insoluble, gel-forming and fermentable fiber.

Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.

Sources

  1. Procter & Gamble. Metamucil 4-in-1 Fiber Orange Sugar-Free, 23.3 oz canister, label archived in NIH DSLD as 291975. Supplement Facts, one rounded teaspoon (5.8 g): 15 calories, 5 g carbohydrate, 3 g dietary fiber, 2 g soluble fiber. https://api.ods.od.nih.gov/dsld/s3/pdf/291975.pdf ↩
  2. Benefiber Original Prebiotic Fiber Supplement, manufacturer’s US product page. Four teaspoons, 6 g dietary fiber and 21% DV; wheat dextrin; directions and gluten-free statement. https://www.benefiber.com/fiber-supplement-products/benefiber-powder/ ↩
  3. McRorie JW. Cereal Foods World, May–June 2020. https://cerealsgrains.org/publications/cfw/2020/May-June/Pages/CFW-65-3-0028.aspx — classification of isolated fibers. text in search results. The author's affiliation was not checked. ↩
  4. Procter & Gamble. Metamucil 4-in-1 Fiber Orange Sugar-Free, 23.3 oz, NIH DSLD 291975. Directions, medicines, choking warning and phenylalanine notice. https://api.ods.od.nih.gov/dsld/s3/pdf/291975.pdf ↩
  5. Marteau P, and colleagues. Gut. 1994. https://doi.org/10.1136/gut.35.12.1747 — PubMed 7829013. Seven healthy adults; 18 g psyllium husk a day for 15 days against placebo. abstract. Funding: not stated in the abstract. ↩

You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.