In 47 adults, chewable lactase lowered breath hydrogen versus a dummy tablet; within visits, symptoms differed at one time point.
Trial · 47 people · 1 dose per test · maker-funded
Baijal and Tandon, JGH Open, 2021
Terms and sources
- 47 adults
- Aged 18 to 65; a breath test showed they digest lactose poorly, with symptoms. Each took both, one after the other, 1 week apart.
- chewable lactase
- Acid lactase from Aspergillus oryzae. Three 4,500 FCC chewable tablets, 13,500 units in all, 5 minutes before 25 g of lactose. Sold in India as Yamoo.
- lowered breath hydrogen
- Lower from 60 minutes on in the first visit and from 90 minutes on in the second; statistically significant. Combined mean at 3 hours: 58 versus 103 ppm.
- within visits, symptoms differed at one time point
- Within each visit, scores differed only at 120 minutes in the second visit. Combined over both visits, scores already differed at time 0, before the lactose. The authors note that symptoms did not track hydrogen.
- a dummy tablet
- placebo, identical in shape, size, color, taste and smell
- maker-funded
- The sponsor, Walter Bushnell Pvt Ltd, gave its Yamoo tablets and the dummy tablets and paid for the breath tests. The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Study · Free full text · about 14 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the free full text in PubMed Central.
Study summary
Researchers compared chewable lactase tablets from Aspergillus oryzae with identical dummy tablets. 47 adults aged 18 to 65 took part; a breath test showed they digest lactose poorly. Each took both, 1 week apart, 5 minutes before 25 g of lactose. Three tablets gave 13,500 FCC units. Breath hydrogen was lower with lactase in both visits, from 60 or 90 minutes on. Within each visit, symptom scores differed only at 120 minutes in one visit. Combined over both visits, scores already differed before the lactose. Funding: the company that sells Yamoo gave the tablets and paid for the breath tests.
In 30 adults, yeast lactase added to milk lowered breath hydrogen and symptom scores versus a dummy additive.
Trial · 30 people · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Montalto et al., European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2005
Terms and sources
- 30 adults
- Aged 18 to 65; breath tests showed they digest lactose poorly, with symptoms. Each had 3 tests in random order.
- yeast lactase added to milk
- Kluyveromyces lactis lactase in 400 mL of milk: 3,000 units 10 hours ahead, or 6,000 units 5 minutes ahead.
- lowered breath hydrogen
- Peak: 12 ppm (10 hours ahead) and 14 ppm (5 minutes ahead) with lactase, 51 ppm with the dummy additive. Statistically significant.
- symptom scores
- Lower with both lactase milks, and lower with the 10-hour milk than the 5-minute milk. Statistically significant.
- a dummy additive
- placebo
- funding not stated
- We could not open the full text to check who paid.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers tested lactase from a yeast, Kluyveromyces lactis, added to milk. 30 adults aged 18 to 65 took part; breath tests showed they digest lactose poorly. Each drank 400 mL of milk three times, in random order. The milk had 3,000 units added 10 hours ahead, 6,000 units added 5 minutes ahead, or a dummy additive. Peak breath hydrogen was 12 and 14 ppm with lactase and 51 ppm with the dummy. Symptom scores were lower with both lactase milks. The differences were statistically significant. Funding: not checked.
In 30 adults reporting reactions to milk, symptom severity did not differ between lactase-treated and regular milk; gas counts did.
Trial · 30 people · 1 week per milk · funding not stated
Suarez et al., New England Journal of Medicine, 1995
Terms and sources
- 30 adults reporting reactions to milk
- They reported severe symptoms after less than 240 mL (8 oz) of milk. Breath tests showed 21 digested lactose poorly and 9 did not.
- lactase-treated
- 240 mL of 2% milk with its lactose split by lactase, daily with breakfast. The regular milk was sweetened with aspartame to match the taste.
- symptom severity did not differ
- Bloating, belly pain, loose stools and gas were rated minimal with both milks. No statistically significant differences.
- gas counts did
- Among the 21 poor digesters, daily gas episodes differed by 2.5 between the milks (95% CI 0.2 to 4.8).
- funding not stated
- PubMed lists US government and other funders. We could not open the full text to check.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared lactase-treated milk with regular milk sweetened to taste the same. 30 adults took part who reported severe symptoms after less than 240 mL of milk. Breath tests showed 21 of them digest lactose poorly. Each drank 240 mL a day with breakfast, one milk for 1 week, then the other. Symptoms were minimal with both milks, and their severity did not differ. Among the 21, daily gas episodes differed by 2.5. The authors write that up to 240 mL of milk a day likely causes negligible symptoms. Funding: not checked.
In 24 adults, chewable lactase lowered breath hydrogen and early symptoms versus a dummy tablet; blood glucose did not differ.
Trial · completed the trial · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Sanders et al., Clinical Pharmacy, 1992
Terms and sources
- 24 adults
- Their breath hydrogen had risen by 20 ppm or more in a lactose test. Each took both, one after the other, at least 1 week apart.
- chewable lactase
- Three tablets, 9,900 FCC units in all, with 8 oz of whole milk plus lactose powder: 50 g of lactose.
- early symptoms
- Ratings for several gut symptoms were lower in the first 8 hours, and bloating in the next 8 hours. The abstract does not say whether these differences were statistically significant.
- blood glucose did not differ
- Plasma glucose, which rises when lactose is digested, did not differ between lactase and the dummy tablet.
- a dummy tablet
- placebo
- funding not stated
- The first author worked for TheraTech, Inc. We could not open the full text to check who paid.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared chewable lactase tablets with dummy tablets. 24 adults completed the trial; their breath hydrogen had risen by 20 ppm or more after lactose. Each took both, one after the other, at least 1 week apart. Three tablets gave 9,900 FCC units, taken with milk holding 50 g of lactose. Peak breath hydrogen was lower with lactase, a statistically significant difference. Ratings for several gut symptoms were lower in the first 8 hours; the abstract does not give their significance. Plasma glucose did not differ. Funding: not checked; the first author worked for TheraTech, Inc.
In 24 adults, acid lactase lowered peak breath hydrogen versus a dummy product; gas fell only at the higher dose.
Trial · 24 people · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
de Vrese et al., Clinical Nutrition, 2015
Terms and sources
- 24 adults
- Adults who digest lactose poorly, with a range of lactase activity. Each tried 5 options, one after the other, with 12.5 g of lactose.
- acid lactase
- From Aspergillus oryzae: 3,300 or 9,000 FCC units. Acid lactase is active in the stomach, the authors note.
- lowered peak breath hydrogen
- By 29% with 3,300 units and 33% with 9,000 units, over 6 hours. One test across all five options was statistically significant.
- the higher dose
- Gas was significantly lower with 9,000 units. A fifth option, 3,300 units plus dried yogurt cultures, lowered hydrogen by 46% and belly pain. That option is a mix.
- a dummy product
- placebo
- funding not stated
- Some authors worked at Tecura GmbH and the Clinical Research Center Kiel. We could not open the full text to check who paid.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers tested acid lactase from Aspergillus oryzae against a dummy product. 24 adults who digest lactose poorly took part. Each tried 5 options, one after the other, with 12.5 g of lactose. The options were a dummy, 3,300 or 9,000 FCC units, dried yogurt cultures, or 3,300 units with cultures. Peak breath hydrogen over 6 hours fell by 29% and 33% with the two lactase doses. Gas was significantly lower only with 9,000 units. The mix with yogurt cultures lowered hydrogen most, by 46%. Funding: not checked.
Lactase lowered breath hydrogen and symptoms versus a dummy pill with 20 g of lactose in milk, not 50 g.
Trial · The abstract does not give the number of participants. · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Lin et al., Digestive Diseases and Sciences, 1993
Terms and sources
- Lactase
- Three products tested in adults who digest lactose poorly: a softgel (Lactogest), a caplet (Lactaid) and a chewable tablet (DairyEase).
- lowered breath hydrogen
- Peak and total hydrogen, with milk holding 20 g of lactose. About 6,000 units lowered it more than about 3,000 units.
- symptoms
- Milder with all three products with 20 g of lactose in milk; statistically significant.
- not 50 g
- 50 g of lactose in water. Hydrogen fell a little, not statistically significantly. Symptom scores did not differ from the dummy pill.
- a dummy pill
- placebo
- funding not stated
- We could not open the full text to check who paid.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared three lactase products and a dummy pill: a softgel, a caplet and a chewable tablet. The participants were adults who digest lactose poorly; the abstract does not give their number. With milk holding 20 g of lactose, all three lowered peak and total breath hydrogen. About 6,000 units lowered it more than about 3,000 units. Symptoms were milder with all products. With 50 g of lactose in water, hydrogen fell a little, not statistically significantly, and symptoms did not differ. Funding: not checked.
In 10 adults, three lactase products differed versus a dummy pill: one lowered breath hydrogen, two lowered symptoms.
Trial · 10 people · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Ramirez et al., American Journal of Gastroenterology, 1994
Terms and sources
- 10 adults
- Healthy volunteers, described by the authors as reacting to lactose. Each ate ice cream with 18 g of lactose.
- three lactase products
- Lactaid, Lactrase and Dairy Ease, taken right before the ice cream. The abstract does not give units per dose. PubMed indexes the trial as single-blind; the abstract does not say.
- one lowered breath hydrogen
- Lactaid lowered peak, total and cumulative hydrogen over 3 hours. It did not lower symptoms.
- two lowered symptoms
- Lactrase lowered pain, bloating and total symptom scores; Dairy Ease lowered pain only. Neither lowered hydrogen.
- a dummy pill
- placebo
- funding not stated
- PubMed lists US government and other funders. We could not open the full text to check.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared three lactase products with a dummy pill. 10 healthy volunteers took part, described by the authors as reacting to lactose. Each ate ice cream with 18 g of lactose right after a product or the dummy pill. Breath hydrogen and symptoms were followed for 3 hours. Only Lactaid lowered breath hydrogen, and it did not lower symptoms. Lactrase lowered pain, bloating and total symptom scores. Dairy Ease lowered pain only. The abstract does not give units per dose. Funding: not checked.
In 40 adults, tilactase before a lactose test lowered peak breath hydrogen and symptom scores versus a dummy pill.
Trial · in the two groups compared; 60 in all · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Ojetti et al., European Review for Medical and Pharmacological Sciences, 2010
Terms and sources
- 40 adults
- The abstract does not say how they were selected; the outcome was whether their breath test returned to normal. 20 took tilactase and 20 a dummy pill.
- tilactase
- Lactase from Aspergillus oryzae (Portincasa 2008), 15 minutes before the breath test. A third group of 20 took the probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri for 10 days; tilactase gave larger changes.
- lowered peak breath hydrogen
- Lower with tilactase than with the dummy pill; statistically significant. More breath tests also returned to normal.
- symptom scores
- Lower with tilactase than with the dummy pill; statistically significant.
- a dummy pill
- placebo
- funding not stated
- PubMed lists non-US government funders. We could not open the full text to check.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers compared tilactase, lactase from Aspergillus oryzae, with a dummy pill and with a probiotic. 60 adults took part, 20 per group; the abstract does not say how they were selected. Tilactase or the dummy pill came 15 minutes before a lactose breath test. With tilactase, more tests returned to normal, and peak breath hydrogen and symptom scores were lower. These differences were statistically significant. The probiotic group, which took Lactobacillus reuteri for 10 days, changed less than the tilactase group. Funding: not checked.
In 16 adults, mold lactase added to milk lowered breath hydrogen and gut symptoms versus a dummy additive.
Trial · 16 people · 1 dose per test · funding not stated
Corazza et al., Alimentary Pharmacology and Therapeutics, 1992
Terms and sources
- 16 adults
- Adults who digest lactose poorly, with symptoms, as the authors describe them. Each had both milks, one after the other.
- mold lactase added to milk
- Lactase from Aspergillus niger in 400 mL of milk. The abstract does not give the units.
- lowered breath hydrogen
- Peak and cumulative hydrogen over 5 hours; statistically significant.
- gut symptoms
- A combined symptom index was lower; statistically significant.
- a dummy additive
- placebo
- funding not stated
- We could not open the full text to check who paid.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. We could not check whether the full text is free.
Study summary
Researchers added lactase from a mold, Aspergillus niger, to milk. 16 adults took part who digest lactose poorly and have symptoms. Each drank 400 mL of milk with lactase and with a dummy additive, one after the other. Breath hydrogen was measured for 5 hours. Peak and cumulative breath hydrogen were lower with lactase. A combined symptom index was also lower. All differences were statistically significant. The abstract does not give the units. Funding: not checked.