Adults with healthy eyes: macular pigment rose at 10 mg a day or more; below 5 mg, no clear change.
Review · 5 weeks to 24 months · industry co-funded
Wilson et al., Advances in Nutrition, 2021
Terms and sources
- Adults with healthy eyes
- Some pooled trials added meso-zeaxanthin or other nutrients; one low-dose trial enrolled adults with excess weight.
- macular pigment
- Macular pigment optical density, a measure of lutein and zeaxanthin in the macula, on a scale of 0 to 1.
- 10 mg a day or more
- Versus a dummy product: 0.04 units higher in the 5 to under 20 mg group. At 20 mg or more: 0.11. Both differences were statistically significant. No placebo-controlled trial in the review used 5 to 10 mg. One smaller trial compared a 6 mg capsule with diet and found no difference.
- no clear change
- Below 5 mg, 3 food-based trials of 0.5–4.5 mg. The difference was not statistically significant. The review rates this evidence very low.
- industry co-funded
- Funded through the Institute for the Advancement of Food and Nutrition Sciences, a nonprofit that pools funding from industry. ILSI North America framed the review question and reviewed the protocol and report. The authors report no conflicts of interest.
Study · Free full text · about 17 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
A 2021 review gathered 46 studies of lutein and zeaxanthin in 3,189 adults with healthy eyes. Most tested supplements; six tested foods. No trial in the review compared 5 to 10 mg with a dummy product. In the 5 to under 20 mg group, supplement trials used 12 mg or more. There, macular pigment rose 0.04 units more than with a dummy product. At 20 mg or more, it rose 0.11 units more. Below 5 mg, in 3 food-based trials, the difference was not statistically significant. The review measured macular pigment, not vision. Funding: a nonprofit that pools industry money.
Healthy adults took lutein with zeaxanthin for 8 weeks; macular pigment did not differ from a dummy capsule.
Trial · supplement study · 8 weeks
Graydon et al., British Journal of Nutrition, 2012
Terms and sources
- lutein with zeaxanthin
- 10 mg of lutein and 5 mg of zeaxanthin a day, from Life Extension. A third group took 15 mg of beta-carotene.
- did not differ
- Measured by Raman spectroscopy, a light-scattering method. Blood lutein rose more than in the other groups; statistically significant.
- a dummy capsule
- Lactose powder in a gelatin capsule.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract. The journal page text was read, but no open license is shown.
Study summary
This trial gave 75 healthy adults lutein with zeaxanthin, beta-carotene or a dummy capsule for 8 weeks. They were 21 to 72 years old. The lutein group took 10 mg of lutein and 5 mg of zeaxanthin a day. Blood lutein rose more than in the other groups. Macular pigment and blood markers of inflammation and oxidation did not differ between groups. A food study in the same paper, with spinach powder, found no difference either. Funding: Safefood, a public food safety body.
Young adults took lutein with zeaxanthin for a year; two of three vision tests differed from a dummy pill.
Trial · 115 people · 1 year · industry author
Hammond et al., Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 2014
Terms and sources
- lutein with zeaxanthin
- 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin a day; the brand is not named in the abstract. Macular pigment and blood lutein rose more than with the dummy pill.
- two of three vision tests
- Recovery after a bright flash and contrast for a yellow target on a blue background differed. Both were statistically significant. Glare tolerance did not differ.
- industry author
- Three of five authors worked at DSM Nutritional Products. We have not read the funding section.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
We could not check whether the full text is free. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial gave 115 young healthy adults lutein with zeaxanthin or a dummy pill for a year. The daily amounts were 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin. Macular pigment and blood lutein rose with the supplement. Recovery of sight after a bright flash was faster than with the dummy pill. Contrast for a yellow target on a blue background also differed. Glare tolerance did not differ. The trial measured lab vision tests, not everyday vision. Funding: not stated in the abstract; three authors worked at DSM Nutritional Products.
In 4 lutein trials in healthy adults, most memory, attention and speed tests did not differ from a dummy product.
Review · 4 lutein trials of 44 to 51 people each in the analysis · 4 months to 1 year · industry co-funded
Nouchi et al., Nutrients, 2020
Terms and sources
- 4 lutein trials
- Lutein with zeaxanthin in 3 trials, lutein alone in 1. They used 10–12 mg a day for 4 months to a year. Three of the trials probably come from one larger US trial; two report older adults and probably overlap. One more trial in the review added meso-zeaxanthin; it is not counted here.
- memory
- Visual memory differed in 1 of 3 trials that tested it; verbal memory in none of 4.
- attention
- Complex attention differed in 1 of 2 trials. Inhibition, holding back a habitual response, differed in 1 of 3. Reasoning did not differ between assigned groups in either of 2.
- speed tests did not differ
- Processing speed did not differ in any of 3 trials.
- industry co-funded
- Lion Corporation backed the review, with grants from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. Six of eight authors were Lion employees.
Study · Free full text · about 25 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
A 2020 review gathered carotenoid trials in adults with normal thinking skills. Four trials compared lutein, alone or with zeaxanthin, with a dummy product for 4 months to a year. Three of them probably come from one larger US trial. Visual memory differed in 1 of 3 trials that tested it, verbal memory in none of 4. Complex attention differed in 1 of 2 trials and inhibition in 1 of 3. Processing speed did not differ in any of 3. A fifth trial added meso-zeaxanthin and is not counted here. Funding: Lion Corporation and Japanese government grants.
Students took lutein with zeaxanthin for a year: visual memory differed from a dummy tablet; 6 other scores did not.
Trial · 51 analyzed · 1 year · industry-funded
Renzi-Hammond et al., Nutrients, 2017
Also counted in Nouchi 2020 and Wilson 2021
Terms and sources
- lutein with zeaxanthin
- 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin a day, one tablet with the highest-fat meal. Macular pigment rose with it.
- visual memory differed
- Statistically significant, in a one-sided test. The abstract also names reasoning and complex attention.
- 6 other scores did not
- Reasoning and complex attention differed only when the authors grouped people by macular pigment change, not by assigned group. 14 of 30 people assigned the dummy tablet were analyzed.
- industry-funded
- Abbott Nutrition paid for the study. DSM supplied the tablets and dummy tablets. The first author worked at Abbott for part of data collection; another author was an Abbott employee.
Study · Free full text · about 19 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PMC full text.
Study summary
This trial assigned 76 healthy college students to lutein with zeaxanthin or a dummy tablet for a year. The daily amounts were 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin. 51 were analyzed: 37 on lutein and 14 on the dummy tablet. Macular pigment rose with lutein. Of 7 thinking scores, only visual memory differed between the assigned groups. Reasoning and complex attention differed only when people were grouped by change in macular pigment. Funding: Abbott Nutrition; DSM supplied the tablets.
Adults took free lutein or lutein esters for 4 weeks; blood lutein rose more per mg with free lutein.
Trial · 72 people · 4 weeks · funding not stated
Norkus et al., Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 2010
Terms and sources
- free lutein or lutein esters
- 12.2 mg of free lutein, or 27 mg of esters equal to 13.5 mg of lutein, each day. Taken with cereal and milk.
- rose more per mg
- Statistically significant from day 21. Over 28 days, the blood response was 17% greater with free lutein.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
We could not check whether the full text is free. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial gave 72 healthy adults aged 23 to 52 either free lutein or lutein esters for 4 weeks. Daily amounts were 12.2 mg of free lutein, or 13.5 mg of lutein as esters. Both were taken with cereal and milk. From day 21, blood lutein per mg taken was higher with free lutein. Over 28 days, the response was 17% greater. There was no dummy pill group. Funding: not stated in the abstract.
Adults took one dose each of lutein esters and free lutein; blood lutein was higher after the esters.
Trial · 18 people · Single doses, blood tests over 17 days · funding not stated
Bowen et al., Journal of Nutrition, 2002
Terms and sources
- one dose each
- In random order, one after the other. Doses were set by body weight.
- higher after the esters
- 61.6% more by the area under the blood curve; statistically significant. Higher in 14 of 18 people.
Study · Access not checked · about 2 min to read
We could not check whether the full text is free. Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial gave 18 healthy adults one dose of lutein diesters and one of free lutein, one after the other. Doses were set by body weight. Blood lutein was measured for 17 days after each dose. With the esters, blood lutein over time was 61.6% higher; the difference was statistically significant. Free lutein dissolved in oil, from earlier studies, gave still higher levels. The authors concluded that how a product dissolves limits absorption more than the ester bond. Funding: not stated in the abstract.