Magnesium malate or glycinate?

Share

Email article

A short crossover included dimagnesium malate and bisglycinate. It is available through EFSA’s account of an unpublished trial.[1] The report does not identify a statistically significant difference between these forms.[1] A separate malate study tested a vitamin mixture; the bisglycinate sleep trial used placebo.[2][3]

What to compareMagnesium malateMagnesium glycinate
CompoundMagnesium bound to malate, derived from malic acid[4]Magnesium bound to glycine; also called bisglycinate[3]
Product studiedA timed-release mixture of dimagnesium malate with vitamins C, B6, folate and B12[2]Bisglycinate capsules supplying magnesium and glycine[3]
Comparison relevant to this pairDimagnesium malate appeared with bisglycinate in the unpublished crossover.[1] The vitamin-mixture study had no glycinate group.[2]Bisglycinate appeared in the unpublished crossover.[1] The sleep trial had no malate group.[3]
Sleep evidence in these sourcesThe mixture study does not establish the sleep effect of malate alone.[2]A small difference from placebo in self-rated sleep problems after four weeks[3]

The short absorption comparison

EFSA describes 14 healthy adults taking each product once, with blood sampling over 24 hours.[1] The comparison included oxide, bisglycinate, buffered bisglycinate and dimagnesium malate.[1] The underlying trial was unpublished; its sleep effects were not tested.[1]

The mixture and the sleep trial

The malate product in the Weiss study contained several ingredients. The study did not isolate the effect of malate.[2] Its results therefore leave open how malate alone compares with glycinate.[2][3]

The sleep trial randomized 155 healthy adults aged 18–65 reporting poor sleep; 153 entered the main analysis.[3] They took 250 mg of elemental magnesium as bisglycinate or placebo daily for four weeks.[3] Adjusted mean sleep problem scores fell by 3.9 points with magnesium and 2.3 points with placebo.[3] The difference in change was 1.6 points on a scale from 0 to 28. The authors described the effect as small.[3] Sleep was self-rated, and the trial did not compare other magnesium forms.[3]

Form and serving

The compound name and the amount of magnesium answer different questions. On US labels, Magnesium in Supplement Facts gives the mineral itself per serving.[5][6] The ingredient list also identifies other ingredients in a mixture.[6]

The magnesium guide explains US intake values, other forms and medicine interactions.

Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.

Sources

  1. EFSA ANS Panel. Evaluation of di-magnesium malate. EFSA Journal. 2018;16(6):5292. Full assessment, section 3.4.1, Human data. doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2018.5292. Read: EFSA account of an unpublished applicant study; the underlying trial report was not read. Funding of the underlying trial was not stated in that account. ↩
  2. Weiss D, Brunk DK, Goodman DA. Scottsdale Magnesium Study: absorption, cellular uptake, and clinical effectiveness of a timed-release magnesium supplement in a standard adult clinical population. Journal of the American College of Nutrition. 2018;37(4):316–327. Publisher full text. PMID 29425476. Read: full text, study design, product composition, Funding and Disclosures. Funding: Artis International Center for Health and Medicine supported the study; Jigsaw Health supplied the supplements. All three authors were independent consultants or advisory-board members for Jigsaw. ↩
  3. Schuster J, Cycelskij I, Lopresti A, Hahn A. Magnesium bisglycinate supplementation in healthy adults reporting poor sleep: a randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Nature and Science of Sleep. 2025;17:2027–2040. Full text. PMID 40918053. Read: full text. Funding: Leibniz University Hannover from its own budget; Biogena made the capsules. ↩
  4. NIH National Library of Medicine, PubChem. Magnesium malate, CID 164748. Compound identity. ↩
  5. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Magnesium: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. Section Dietary Supplements. ↩
  6. US Code of Federal Regulations. 21 CFR 101.36, nutrition labeling of dietary supplements, paragraphs (b)(2)(ii) and (d). ↩