In 4 ginseng extract trials in healthy adults, some test scores differed from a dummy product; evidence was unconvincing.
Review · not stated as one number · 2 days to 12 weeks
Geng et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2010
Terms and sources
- 4 ginseng extract trials
- Of 9 trials found, 8 enrolled healthy adults. Four extract trials had usable data, at 200–400 mg a day. A fifth trial tested a blend of Panax ginseng with other plants, including Siberian ginseng; it is not counted here.
- some test scores
- Some measures of thinking, behavior and quality of life. The trials differed too much to be combined.
- a dummy product
- placebo
- evidence was unconvincing
- The authors found no convincing evidence of an effect on thinking in healthy adults. They also found Kennedy 2001 and Reay 2005 but could not use their data.
Study · Free full text · about 61 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the free full text in PMC, without the tables of trials.
Study summary
A 2010 Cochrane review looked for trials of ginseng and thinking. It found 9 trials; 8 enrolled healthy adults. Four trials of ginseng extracts, at 200–400 mg a day, had data the authors could use. A fifth tested a blend of ginseng with other plants, including Siberian ginseng. The trials could not be combined. Some measures of thinking, behavior and quality of life differed from a dummy product. The authors found no convincing evidence of an effect on thinking in healthy adults. Funding: the authors' university and the Chinese Cochrane Center; no known conflicts of interest.
Healthy adults took Korean red ginseng for 8 weeks; combined thinking-test scores rose more than with a dummy pill.
Trial · 51 people · 8 weeks · funding not stated
Namgung et al., Human Psychopharmacology, 2021
Terms and sources
- Healthy adults
- 51 people: 26 took red ginseng and 25 the dummy pill. Ages are not stated in the abstract.
- Korean red ginseng
- 1,000 mg a day. The ginsenoside share is not stated in the Namgung abstract.
- combined thinking-test scores
- A combined score of planning, attention and memory tests; the difference was statistically significant. On brain scans, gray matter in one area also rose more.
- a dummy pill
- placebo
- funding not stated
- The abstract does not name who paid for the study or supplied the product. We could not open the full text.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial compared Korean red ginseng with a dummy pill. 51 healthy adults took 1,000 mg a day or the dummy pill for 8 weeks. A combined score of planning, attention and memory tests rose more with red ginseng. This difference was statistically significant. On brain scans, gray matter volume in one area rose more with red ginseng. The abstract does not give ages or the ginsenoside share of the product. Funding: not stated in the abstract; we could not open the full text.
Healthy, tired adults took Korean red ginseng for 3 weeks; tiredness scores fell more than with a dummy tablet.
Trial · 46 people · 3 weeks
Lee et al., Journal of Ginseng Research, 2025
Terms and sources
- Healthy, tired adults
- Japanese adults aged 40–60 who felt tired every day and rated it fairly high at the start.
- Korean red ginseng
- 2 tablets a day, each with 480 mg of red ginseng powder. The Methods also say 500 mg a day. The ginsenoside share is not stated.
- tiredness scores
- Both groups started at about 64 mm on a 100 mm scale. After 3 weeks: 38.8 mm versus 50.1 mm, statistically significant. Blood cortisol and lactate did not differ.
- a dummy tablet
- placebo
Study · Free full text · about 19 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the free full text in PMC.
Study summary
This trial compared Korean red ginseng with a dummy tablet. 46 healthy Japanese adults aged 40–60 who felt tired every day took part for 3 weeks. Each took 2 tablets a day, each with 480 mg of red ginseng powder. Tiredness was rated on a 100 mm scale. After 3 weeks, it was 38.8 mm with red ginseng and 50.1 mm with the dummy tablet. This difference was statistically significant. Blood cortisol, lactate, other blood and urine tests and side effects did not differ. Funding: the Korean agriculture ministry, through an agri-food export program.
Office workers took HRG80 or a standard ginseng for 2 weeks; attention differed from a dummy capsule only with HRG80.
Trial · each took all three products · 2 weeks per product · maker-funded
Mariage et al., Pharmaceuticals (Basel), 2020
Terms and sources
- Office workers
- 50 healthy, tired call-center, engineering and IT workers aged 18–65. Each took all three products, one after the other.
- HRG80
- Red ginseng from roots grown in water culture. By the Methods, 2 capsules a day held about 63 mg of ginsenosides. The report's appendix gives 15.88 mg per capsule instead.
- a standard ginseng
- A root powder from Arkopharma: 2 capsules held about 20 mg of ginsenosides. The abstract calls it white ginseng; the Methods call it red.
- attention
- Errors on an attention test at the end of the workday. Memory and stress scores differed from the dummy capsule with both products. HRG80 also differed from the standard ginseng on attention and stress scores, not on memory. The abstract's conclusion says memory too.
- a dummy capsule
- placebo: rice flour and brown sugar
- maker-funded
- Botalys, maker of HRG80, and Europharma USA paid for part of the work. Botalys supplied HRG80; the first author is its co-CEO.
Study · Free full text · about 27 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the free full text in PMC.
Study summary
This trial compared two ginseng products with a dummy capsule. 50 healthy, tired office workers took each for 2 weeks, one after the other. HRG80 is red ginseng from roots grown in water culture. The other was a standard root powder. Attention errors at the end of the workday differed from the dummy capsule only with HRG80. Memory and stress scores differed from the dummy capsule with both products. The authors made no correction for multiple tests. Funding: in part by Botalys, maker of HRG80, and Europharma USA.
Young adults took one dose of G115; rated mental tiredness during tasks was lower than with a dummy pill.
Trial · 30 people · single doses · funding not stated
Reay et al., Journal of Psychopharmacology, 2005
Terms and sources
- Young adults
- 30 healthy young adults. Each took 200 mg, 400 mg and a dummy pill on different days, one after the other.
- G115
- A standardized Panax ginseng extract. The result in the headline is for 200 mg. The abstract names 200 mg as giving the most notable effects.
- rated mental tiredness
- Rated after each round of tasks for about an hour; lower at all but one time, statistically significant. Blood sugar fell with both doses.
- a dummy pill
- placebo
- funding not stated
- The abstract does not name who paid for the study or supplied the product. We could not open the full text.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial compared single doses of ginseng G115 with a dummy pill. 30 healthy young adults took 200 mg, 400 mg and the dummy pill on different days. An hour after each dose, they did mental tasks for about an hour. With 200 mg, rated mental tiredness was lower at all but one time, a statistically significant difference. Counting backward by sevens also scored higher with 200 mg. Blood sugar fell with both doses. The abstract names 200 mg as giving the most notable effects. Funding: not stated in the abstract.
Adults took single doses of G115; memory scores rose at 400 mg, attention speed fell at 200 and 600 mg.
Trial · 20 people · single doses · funding not stated
Kennedy et al., Nutritional Neuroscience, 2001
Terms and sources
- Adults
- 20 healthy young adults. Each took 200, 400 and 600 mg and a dummy pill on different days, one after the other.
- G115
- A Panax ginseng extract from Pharmaton.
- memory scores
- A quality-of-memory score, compared with the dummy pill (placebo), at all test times after 400 mg.
- attention speed
- Slower at later test times. Self-rated alertness was also lower 6 hours after 200 and 400 mg.
- funding not stated
- The abstract does not name who paid for the study or supplied the product. We could not open the full text.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial compared single doses of ginseng G115 with a dummy pill. 20 healthy young adults took 200, 400 and 600 mg and the dummy pill on different days. Tests ran 1 to 6 hours after each dose. With 400 mg, a memory score was higher at all test times. With 200 and 600 mg, attention was slower at later times. Self-rated alertness was lower 6 hours after 200 and 400 mg. Funding: not stated in the abstract; we could not open the full text.
Young adults took ginseng G115 for 8 weeks; mood scores did not differ from a dummy pill.
Trial · 83 people · 8 weeks · funding not stated
Cardinal and Engels, Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 2001
Terms and sources
- Young adults
- 83 adults with an average age of 25.7, from a university and health clubs.
- G115
- 200 or 400 mg a day of the Panax ginseng extract G115. The authors call 200 mg the recommended level.
- mood scores
- Positive feelings, negative feelings and a total mood score.
- a dummy pill
- placebo: lactose
- funding not stated
- The abstract does not name who paid for the study or supplied the product. We could not open the full text.
Study · Abstract only · about 2 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the PubMed abstract.
Study summary
This trial compared ginseng G115 with a dummy pill. 83 adults, average age 25.7, took 200 mg, 400 mg or the dummy pill daily for 8 weeks. The trial measured positive feelings, negative feelings and a total mood score. None of these differed between the groups. The authors call 200 mg the recommended level. Funding: not stated in the abstract; we could not open the full text.
Healthy adults took ginseng extract for 4 weeks; side effects and blood tests did not differ from a dummy capsule.
Trial · 170 people · 4 weeks
Lee et al., Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 2012
Terms and sources
- Healthy adults
- 170 Korean adults aged 18–60. People with past reactions to ginseng were excluded.
- ginseng extract
- A 20% ethanol extract of 4-year-old root, 1 g or 2 g a day; ginsenoside share not stated.
- side effects
- Reported by 34% with 1 g, 30% with 2 g and 32% with the dummy capsule; not statistically significant. All were rated mild. A 4-week trial of 170 people cannot show rare or long-term side effects.
- a dummy capsule
- placebo
Study · Free full text · about 21 min to read
Our estimate at about 200 words a minute, from the free full text in PMC.
Study summary
This trial compared Panax ginseng root extract with a dummy capsule. 170 healthy Korean adults aged 18–60 took 1 g, 2 g or the dummy capsule daily for 4 weeks. Side effects were reported by 34%, 30% and 32% of the three groups. The difference was not statistically significant. Two people on 2 g stopped early, with a fast pulse and poor sleep, or a rash and nausea. Blood tests did not differ. Funding: a Korean government science foundation.