No. 17
The Verateca TablePeriodic Table of Supplements

Vitamin D2 and D3: forms, blood levels and sources

D2 and D3 both can raise the usual blood marker of vitamin D status.[1] Direct comparisons have often found a greater rise with D3.[1][2] That finding concerns the blood marker.[2] The comparison below did not measure fractures or changes in well-being.[2]

The names on the label

D2 is ergocalciferol.[1] D3 is cholecalciferol.[1] Both forms are absorbed in the small intestine and undergo further conversion in the body.[1] Their effect on 25(OH)D combines absorption and subsequent metabolism.[1]

The historical name D1 referred to a preparation containing D2 and lumisterol.[4] D2 and D3 are the two forms typically listed on supplement labels.[1]

A label's amount per serving and its form answer separate questions.[1] The vitamin D guide explains mcg, IU, US reference intakes and the total across products.

A direct comparison at the same amount

Fortified foods through winter — Tripkovic and colleagues, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2017.[2] The British trial randomized 335 healthy South Asian and white European women aged 20–64.[2] It compared D2 and D3 in juice or biscuits, each providing 15 mcg daily, with unfortified foods.[2] Follow-up lasted 12 weeks.[2] 44 participants did not complete the trial.[2] The trial was double-blind and measured total blood 25(OH)D.[2]

The D3-versus-D2 difference in change was 15.3 nmol/L for biscuits and 16.9 nmol/L for juice.[2] Both differences were statistically significant.[2] These results belong to the tested foods, winter conditions and participants.[2] The trial did not compare fractures, symptoms or capsule tolerability.[2] Read: accepted full manuscript. Funding: BBSRC DRINC.[2] One author was D3Tex research director. D3Tex held a patent on UVB-transmitting material.[2]

Vegan ingredients and the capsule

D2 can come from fungi or yeast.[3] Commercial D3 can come from lanolin, obtained from sheep's wool, or from lichen.[3] The name D3 alone does not identify its origin.[3]

The capsule is a separate part of the product.[3] Gelatin can be animal-derived even when the vitamin's source fits a vegetarian or vegan diet.[3] The active ingredient, its source and the other ingredients therefore need separate checks on the specific label.[3]

A manufacturer's statement may resolve an origin that the label leaves unspecified.[3] These details concern the product's composition.[2][3] The blood-marker trial did not compare vegan claims.[2][3]

Reading a comparison in context

The amount swallowed, the blood concentration and a clinical outcome each require their own evidence.[1][2] A higher average 25(OH)D response does not establish a universal advantage for every outcome.[2] Blood tests and reference levels explains what that marker describes.

Information, not a prescription. Do not start, stop or combine supplements or medicines on your own.

Sources

  1. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Vitamin D: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. Introduction and Dietary supplements. The form comparison concerns measured vitamin D status. ↩
  2. Tripkovic L, et al. D2 and D3 in fortified foods during winter. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2017. Accepted full manuscript. Original publication. Read: design, results, withdrawals, discussion and funding. Blood-marker comparison; other populations and clinical outcomes require separate evidence. Funding: BBSRC DRINC BB/I006192/1; the funder had no role in design or analysis. One author was D3Tex research director. D3Tex held a patent on UVB-transmitting material. ↩
  3. NHS Specialist Pharmacy Service. Choosing vitamin D products for vegetarians or vegans. Active ingredients and Excipients. Used for ingredient origins and capsule composition; British prescribing and licensing rules are outside this US article. ↩
  4. Windaus A, Lüttringhaus A, Deppe M. Über das krystallisierte Vitamin D1. Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie. 1931. Original report. Windaus A, Dithmar K, Fernholz E. Über das Lumisterin. 1932. Follow-up. Original citations checked at the bibliographic level. The account of the preparation follows DeLuca’s historical review. ↩

You may quote, republish or translate this article under CC BY 4.0: credit “Verateca”, link to this page and indicate changes, including translations. Quotes from NIH, FDA and other sources, label texts and prices are not covered by this license.